Pull up a seat on the couch—bourbon not required but highly recommended—as Shrink the Nation tackles the psychological circus of presidential expectations. Why do Americans keep expecting their presidents to be Marvel superheroes (or at least build us flying cars)? Why does disappointment so often turn to scapegoating and hysteria? And what does infantile defense have to do with politics, family fights, or your group chat?

Dr. David, Rob, Keith, and Amit dig into the deep end of projection—the classic Freudian defense that explains why we pin all our hopes, fears, and hot takes on whoever is in the White House. From Reagan in a flying car to JFK’s legendary “affairs,” the crew dissects how childhood fantasy morphs into adult cynicism (and, sometimes, just more bourbon).

We break down:

Why political projection isn’t just about hope—it’s about primitive psychotic defense (thanks, Melanie Klein, and yes, we explain “paranoid-schizoid split” in plain English).
How society keeps falling for the “hero or villain” trap, whether it’s Salem witch trials, cult logic, or 4D chess politicians.
Scapegoating in American life: what Different Strokes’ “bicycle man” and family therapy have in common with cable news.
How media and social media feed the hysteria—and why no president, not even with snacks and a cape, can fix your life for you.
Why the prescription is more local action, more personal responsibility, and (yes) more snacks.

Pop Culture & Citations:

Bedtime for Bonzo, Different Strokes (“the bicycle man”), JFK & Marilyn Monroe, Salem Witch Trials, Melanie Klein (paranoid-schizoid split), DBT (Dialectical Behavior Therapy), “4D chess,” the “attention economy,” Army resilience training (“hunt the good stuff”).

You’ll laugh, maybe groan, and definitely leave with a smarter, more integrated take on politics, leadership, and why looking for “the good” (even in Congress) is the sanest move you can make.

"Got Thoughts? Outrage? A Diagnosis of Your Own? Send us a text"

Support the show

Shrink The Nation is where America lies on the couch — and we pour the bourbon.
Hosted by board-certified psychiatrists and mental health pros with backgrounds in military, media, and systems thinking, we break down the psychology behind politics, culture, and public dysfunction.
Smart. Funny. Clinically sharp. Slightly buzzed.

Subscribe, rate, and share if you’re part of the exhausted middle looking for sanity in the noise.

Send us your questions (or your defense mechanisms): socials@shrinkthenation.com
Follow us everywhere: @shrinkthenation on X, Instagram, Facebook and Bluesky

Shrink The Nation — On the Couch With America.

Stephen Shaw

The AI-powered Podcast Player