Mr. Post (Counsel for Respondent Palmquist)
Appellate counsel representing the respondents (Palmquist), arguing that federal courts cannot acquire jurisdiction through error and that the judgment should be vacated because complete diversity was lacking at removal.
Best podcasts with Mr. Post (Counsel for Respondent Palmquist)
Ranked by the Snipd community
Nov 4, 2025 • 42min
[24-724] Hain Celestial Group, Inc. v. Palmquist
In this discussion, Ms. Harrington represents Hain Celestial Group, emphasizing the importance of preserving final judgments despite a non-diverse defendant's dismissal. Mr. Post counters by asserting that federal courts cannot gain jurisdiction through error and stresses the implications of such removals. Topics span jurisdictional defects, the fairness of dismissals, and the plaintiff's forum choice rights. The debate reveals intricate legal principles and the potential consequences of each argument on future cases.
