Detective John Diebel, the lead investigator, unravels a complex homicide case involving Dr. Stephen Schwartz, whose death raises chilling questions. Leo Straugei, a handyman tied to the family, shifts from witness to suspect, revealing conflicting stories. At the center is Rebecca Schwartz, who faces scrutiny over financial motives linked to her husband's death. Their son, Carter, stresses the family's quest for justice amid shocking allegations and a civil lawsuit, leading to a staggering jury verdict against Rebecca.