Journalist Andrea Canning and true crime veteran Josh Mankiewicz delve into the gripping case of Katelyn Markham, a 21-year-old art student who vanished in 2011. They discuss the decade-long investigation that finally led to an arrest, including insights from the investigator who broke the case. The conversation touches on law enforcement's early missteps, the impact of private investigations, and the emotional toll on Katelyn’s family. Expect humor and poignant revelations as they explore the complexities of justice.