Jimmy Akin and Dom Bettinelli explore the infamous 1958 poltergeist case involving a Catholic family in New York. They discuss the strange events, such as popping bottle caps and moving objects, and explore theories behind the paranormal activity. They also investigate the possibility of a demon's involvement and test the effects of pressure on screw top bottles. The hosts discuss the weaknesses of the family hoax explanation and explore signs of suppressed anger and anxiety in one family member.