Greg Sorenson, a detective with the Santa Barbara Sheriff's Department, delves into the chilling case of Jarrod Davidson's murder in 2004. He unravels a web of family tensions and the complexities of a custody battle that escalated to violence. The investigation exposes shocking evidence, including a mysterious gift card tied to a suspect, and the emotional toll on Jarrod's young daughter, Malia. Sorenson shares gripping insights into a trial marked by deep family ties, conflicting testimonies, and the struggle for justice amidst heart-wrenching grief.