Timothy Noah, a staff writer at The New Republic, champions Joe Biden's presidency as transformative, highlighting major achievements like the infrastructure program and healthcare expansion. In contrast, Gil Troy, a presidential historian at McGill University, critiques Biden's leadership amid inflation and foreign policy missteps. The debate delves into Biden's controversial pardons, his foreign policy challenges, and the contrasting perspectives on whether history will ultimately view him favorably. Engaging insights make for a captivating discussion.