Elizabeth Oldfield, a former director of Theos and host of The Sacred, joins Rhodri Davies, a philanthropy expert, Gerald Moore, a philosophy professor, and Sophie Scott Brown, a historian and philosopher. They dive into the complexities of gift-giving, discussing reciprocity's role in society and the emotional significance behind gifts. The conversation spans philanthropy's ethical dilemmas, the impact of gratitude in contemporary capitalism, and the historical context of charitable acts, all while critiquing the colonial legacies of Thanksgiving.