Former historian of Joseph Smith and the LDS Church, Don Bradley, speaks about his journey of leaving and returning to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He discusses the complexity of Joseph Smith's motives in practicing polygamy and challenges assumptions about his sincerity. The chapter also explores various perspectives on people leaving the LDS Church and highlights the role of gratitude in rediscovering faith.

Stephen interviews Don Bradley, an LDS Polygamy and Joseph Smith Historian. They discuss his journey of leaving and returning to the LDS church, his struggles with doubt and questioning, the role of doubt in purifying faith, the Book of Mormon as a witness of Christ, discoveries of pious forgeries, the fine-tuning problem in the universe, reflections on the existence of God and the afterlife, and his rediscovery of Christianity and belief in the resurrection of Jesus.

A church historian, disillusioned by Joseph Smith, removed his records but found his faith strengthened after further study. He discovered connections between the Nauvoo endowment and the Book of Mormon, as well as in accounts of Joseph Smith's first vision and seer stone. His journey navigates faith crisis, departure from the LDS church, and eventual return through exploration of gratitude and fine tuning of the universe's constants