Cindy Short, an attorney with a personal connection to abduction, and reporter Jim Spellman, who covered the Lisa Irwin case, dive into the gripping details surrounding Baby Lisa's disappearance. They discuss a mysterious man seen with a baby and the scrutiny on Lisa's mother, revealing the impact of media narratives on police investigations. Witness accounts and evolving suspect profiles add layers to the intriguing puzzle, while Short’s insights shed light on the emotional toll of such cases on families.

Megan Wright, the ex-girlfriend of John Tanko, shares insights about a mysterious phone call received the night Baby Lisa went missing. Living in a tumultuous environment, Wright recounts her struggles with addiction and how they intertwined with the case. Kansas City attorney Cindy Short discusses crucial information uncovered from Tanko during their jailhouse meetings, including the existence of three significant cell phones. Tension mounts as law enforcement experts weigh in on the unresolved questions and emotional stakes surrounding this heartbreaking disappearance.