Casey Chalk, author of 'The Obscurity of Scripture,' discusses why we need a magisterium and cannot rely upon the clarity of the Bible alone. They explore the new perspective on Paul and its impact on the speaker's conversion to Catholicism. The chapter discusses the concept of biblical perspicuity in Protestantism, its challenges and different interpretations. It examines the tensions it creates, objections to perspicuity, and the role of critical scholarship and the magisterium in scripture interpretation.

Author Casey Chalk explores the contrasting perspectives on the Bible between Catholicism and Protestantism, focusing on the concept of perspicuity and its implications for understanding the Christian faith. He discusses the ongoing debate among reformers about the essentials of the Christian faith and how the interpretation of John's Gospel challenges the belief in sola scriptura. Chalk also explores the concept of scripture clarity and obscurity within Catholicism and Protestantism, highlighting the role of the Catholic Church in confirming interpretations of scripture. He emphasizes the importance of the Church in interpreting Scripture and defining key doctrines, discussing the need for an external authority, like the Church, to provide certainty and guidance. Chalk concludes by discussing the reasons why Protestants should submit to the authority of the Catholic Church in regard to scriptural interpretation, highlighting the challenges faced by Protestantism and the confident interpretive power of Catholicism.