Episode 79: J.J. Kimche & Daniel A. Klein "Letters on Kabbalah"

Embark on a fascinating journey through the corridors of Jewish history as we unravel the enigmatic and controversial discussions surrounding the authenticity of the Zohar and the profound role of Kabbalah in Jewish thought and practice. For the first time ever, J.J. Kimche and Daniel A. Klein, authors of the groundbreaking new book "Letters on Kabbalah," present an exclusive compilation of correspondences, meticulously translated into English. These monumental letters, penned by four distinguished Jewish leaders — Rabbi Abraham Yitzhak Kook, Rabbi Yihye Qafih, Rabbi Eliyahu Benamozegh, and Shadal — offer a captivating exploration into the diverse perspectives, doctrines, and ideologies of two contrasting yet traditional schools of Jewish thought. The podcast shines a spotlight on the spirited exchange between Shadal and Rabbi Benamozegh, two towering figures who give us a glimpse into their feisty personalities and sharp wits. This in-depth discussion not only illuminates their contrasting viewpoints but also provides a unique window into the dynamic world of Jewish intellectual discourse. The relationship between traditional rabbinic Judaism and Kabbalah has been complex and varied throughout history. While Kabbalah has been embraced by many, some of the greatest rabbis in history pushed back against its influence because either they felt some of the concepts deviate from fundamental beliefs which may lead to heretical interpretations, or that it distracted from the practical aspects of Jewish observance and placed too much emphasis on speculative ideas, or that the hidden nature of Kabbalistic texts can make it susceptible to misinterpretation, among other reasons. Nevertheless, it is undoubtedly worthwhile to analyze and comprehend the differences in perspectives and appreciate why this conversation continues to be relevant today.