Explore the striking absence of queer identity in conservative Christian beliefs and its troubling consequences. Delve into personal stories that illuminate the marginalization of queer experiences in discussions of gender. Unpack the paradox within high-control religions, where queerness is seen as both non-existent and a threat. The conversation highlights the urgent need for acknowledgment and understanding of LGBTQ+ identities to combat violence and discrimination.
Conservative high-control religions ignore and erase queer identities within their frameworks of sex and gender, leading to harmful societal repercussions.
Despite denying queer existence, these ideologies paradoxically view queerness as a major threat to their perceived natural order, promoting violence and exclusion.
Deep dives
The Absence of Queer Identity in Conservative Religion
Conservative high-control religions often ignore queer identity and expression in their ideologies around sex and gender. This absence is notable in their teachings, where discussions about gender or sexuality rarely address queer perspectives, leading to a culture where queerness is fundamentally absent. As a result, individuals who identify as queer find themselves erased from the conversation, reinforcing a belief that queer identities are simply deviant. The lack of recognition for queer identities ultimately contributes to negative repercussions, including violence against the LGBTQ+ community.
Queerness as an Existential Threat
Despite not formally acknowledging queer existence, high-control religions often frame queerness as an existential threat to their values and societal norms. The ideology claims that queer identities undermine the 'natural' order, presenting a paradox where the absence of queerness is perceived as a significant threat. This leads adherents to vehemently oppose queer concepts, driven by a perceived obligation to protect what they view as divinely sanctioned standards. Such fixation on queerness reveals a dual logic where its non-acceptance magnifies its perceived dangers.
Violence Justified by Ideological Claims
The perceptions fostered within conservative high-control religions not only erase queer identities but also justify societal and personal violence against the LGBTQ+ community. Practices like conversion therapy and familial rejection are rationalized as jarring attempts to steer individuals back to their supposed 'authentic' identity. Adherents believe that such interventions are necessary for preserving moral and social order, often disregarding the harm inflicted on queer individuals. Ultimately, this framework perpetuates a cycle of violence and exclusion, positioning queer identities as threats rather than valid expressions of human experience.
Subscribe for $5.99 a month to get bonus content most Mondays, bonus episodes every month, ad-free listening, access to the entire 750-episode archive, Discord access, and more: https://axismundi.supercast.com/
Subscribe to One Nation, Indivisible with Andrew Seidel:
Why is there no acknowledgement of queer identity or expression within the sex/gender ideology of conservative high-control Christianity? What does this tell us about how queerness is understood within this subculture? And why is queer identity simultaneously denied and perceived as an existential threat? Check out this week’s episode to hear what Dan has to say.