Jonah Goldberg, co-founder and Editor-in-Chief of The Dispatch and a prominent columnist, joins the conversation to delve into the perils of Trump's second term. They tackle Trump's tariffs, the influence of fringe thinkers like Curtis Yarvin on tech leaders, and the disturbing rise of anti-Semitism within conservatism. The discussion highlights Trump's mob-like political tactics and the dangers of loyalty over integrity in governance. Goldberg also critiques corporate logic's encroachment into politics, raising alarm over the erosion of democratic values.
Trump's influence has cultivated a political environment where loyalty often overshadows ethical governance, raising concerns about potential authoritarianism.
Despite significant controversies, many Republican voters prioritize personal economic interests, demonstrating a disconnect between core supporters and broader public sentiment.
The rise of authoritarian thought within the Republican Party, fueled by tech billionaires and fringe ideas, poses a threat to traditional democratic norms.
Deep dives
Trump's First Term and Nostalgia
The perception of Trump's first term among his supporters is often overly nostalgic, focusing on perceived successes while downplaying significant controversies. Many supporters argue that despite chaotic moments, the economy thrived, leading them to believe a second Trump term would replicate that success without acknowledging the influence of more moderate Republicans who constrained his power. The lack of challenges from loyalists surrounding Trump in his current term raises concerns about potential authoritarianism and the absence of dissent to prevent poor decision-making. This situation highlights the importance of accountability and the need for voices that can push back against the unchecked ambitions of a president with deeply ingrained loyalty demands.
Shifts in Republican Voter Dynamics
Recent elections have revealed that many Republican voters remain largely unconcerned about Trump's controversies, often prioritizing personal economic interests over ethical considerations. Polling data indicates a disconnect between the desires of Trump’s core supporters and broader sentiments regarding controversial actions, such as the pardoning of January 6 rioters. This disparity suggests that many voters are focused on specific issues like inflation and immigration, rather than the implications of Trump's actions or character. The perception of Trump's mandate may be inflated, and it becomes critical to understand how this disconnect shapes the future of the Republican Party.
Influence of Tech Entrepreneurs
The rise of figures like Curtis Yarvin and the influence of tech billionaires such as Peter Thiel and Marc Andreessen on Trump's administration raises significant concerns about the ideological direction of the party. They have fostered a culture of authoritarian thought that prioritizes power and opposition to traditional governance structures, distancing themselves from the values of decentralized democracy. As these individuals endorse candidates like J.D. Vance, who promote fantastical ideas of America’s economic future, there’s a palpable shift towards an authoritarianism disguised as populism, which threatens democratic norms. Ultimately, the embrace of fringe ideas by mainstream figures illustrates a severe departure from conservative principles.
Corruption Through Tariffs and Favoritism
The concept of tariffs within the Trump administration has been associated with political corruption, often used to create incentives for special interests seeking favors from the government. Tariffs inherently provide a mechanism for political patronage, allowing the administration to leverage regulatory power to benefit select groups. This dynamic fosters an environment of favoritism that mirrors mob-like tactics, where personal loyalty outweighs ethical governance. Understanding the relationship between tariffs and corruption is crucial in dissecting the broader implications of Trump's economic policies on American politics.
The Consequences of Anger and Division
The political environment in America has become increasingly polarized, with expressions of loyalty to either the right or the left often overshadowing discussions about truth and accountability. This anger-driven phenomenon prevents open dialogues about the implications of Trump's actions and policies. Many Republican officials express fears about reprisal should they criticize Trump, leading to a culture of silence and complicity that is damaging to democratic institutions. The result is a stark suppression of dissent within the party, creating a barrier for constructive discourse and limiting the potential for reform.
Populism's Impact on Governance
The populist wave that propelled Trump into the spotlight continues to affect governance, where personal allegiance often overrides traditional principles of conservatism. The blend of nationalism and statism expressed by Trump undermines the foundational ideals of limited government and individual liberty, leaving a profound impact on the political landscape. As political rhetoric shifts towards glorifying strength and authority, it risks abandoning the values of humility and virtue that are essential for a healthy democracy. This evolution, driven by social media and tribal allegiances, creates a problematic scenario where fidelity to political idols becomes more important than maintaining the integrity of democratic institutions.
Sam Harris speaks with Jonah Goldberg about the damage Trump is doing domestically and abroad. They discuss Trump’s tariffs, Curtis Yarvin and the Tech Right, threats against Republicans who criticize Trump, why the arguments Republicans are using to defend Trump’s position on Ukraine are flawed, America’s deteriorating moral standing on the global stage, the recklessness of DOGE, why so many CEOs bent the knee to Trump, antisemitism on the Right, Trump’s plan for Gaza, worst case scenarios for Trump 2.0, and other topics.
Jonah Goldberg is the co-founder and Editor-in-Chief of The Dispatch. A Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Goldberg is also an LA Times columnist, CNN contributor, and three-time bestselling author.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
