The hosts discuss the scandal between two podcasters, exploring the reasons for their falling out. They analyze the media's framing of the story and delve into the background of the original co-hosts. The alleged Christmas party altercation is discussed, along with the success of the Call Her Daddy podcast and the introduction of a new erotic stories series. The dark undertones of the podcast and the business aspects of the breakup are explored. The hosts reflect on the challenges of researching a story involving criticized individuals and tease the next episode.
51:56
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The Call Her Daddy podcast experienced a dramatic fallout due to a contentious contract dispute with their media company, highlighting the challenges of balancing creative freedom and financial agreements in the podcasting industry.
Call Her Daddy broke boundaries and empowered marginalized voices by openly discussing sex and relationships, becoming a cultural phenomenon that showcased the influence and power of podcasts in shaping cultural conversations.
The personal and professional betrayals that occurred during the Call Her Daddy fallout serve as a cautionary tale on the potential consequences of mixing personal relationships with professional endeavors.
Deep dives
The Fall of a Podcast Empire
Sophia Franklin and Alex Cooper, co-hosts of the popular podcast Call Her Daddy, experienced a dramatic and controversial fallout that resulted in the dissolution of their friendship and the future of the podcast hanging in the balance. The podcast, known for its candid discussions about relationships and sexuality, quickly gained a massive following and became a huge success. However, tensions arose when negotiations for a new contract with their media company, Bastl Sports, turned sour. The dispute centered around the ownership of the podcast's intellectual property, with Alex and Sophia demanding more control and a bigger share of the profits. In a 2020 podcast episode, Bastl Sports founder Dave Portnoy revealed his side of the story, accusing Sophia's boyfriend, Suitman, of manipulating the situation and influencing Sophia's decisions. Despite offers from Bastl Sports to renegotiate the contract and grant more favorable terms, the relationship between the hosts and the company deteriorated. The podcast went on hiatus, leaving fans eager for answers and fueling speculation about its future. The fallout of Call Her Daddy serves as a cautionary tale about the challenges of navigating the business side of podcasting and the complexities that can arise when success and personal relationships collide.
The Power of a Popular Podcast
Call Her Daddy, hosted by Sophia Franklin and Alex Cooper, quickly grew in popularity, amassing millions of listeners and becoming a cultural phenomenon. The podcast, known for its explicit and unapologetic discussions about sex and relationships, broke boundaries and challenged traditional norms surrounding female sexuality. It provided a platform for open dialogue and became a voice for the millennial and Gen Z generation. With their authentic and relatable approach, Sophia and Alex captured the attention of listeners worldwide, creating a dedicated fan base known as the Daddy Gang. The success of Call Her Daddy solidified the influence and power that podcasts can have in shaping cultural conversations and empowering marginalized voices.
A Contentious Contract Dispute
The downfall of Call Her Daddy stemmed from a contentious contract dispute between the hosts and their media company, Bastl Sports. As the podcast gained immense popularity, Sophia and Alex sought to assert more control over their intellectual property and secure a larger share of the profits. Negotiations between the parties were met with disagreements and clashes over ownership and financial terms. Dave Portnoy, founder of Bastl Sports, offered multiple deals and compromises in an attempt to salvage the partnership, including returning the intellectual property rights to the hosts. However, tensions and miscommunication persisted, leading to a breakdown in the relationship and the podcast going on hiatus. The contract dispute highlights the challenges and complexities of balancing creative freedom, financial agreements, and personal relationships in the podcasting industry.
Personal and Professional Betrayals
The fallout from the Call Her Daddy dispute was not only a battle over contracts and financial terms, but also involved personal and professional betrayals. Sophia Franklin and Alex Cooper, once best friends and co-hosts, found their friendship deteriorating amidst the negotiations and public scrutiny. Accusations of greed, disloyalty, and manipulation were thrown around, further straining the already fragile relationship between the hosts. Sophia's boyfriend, Suitman, became a central figure in the narrative, with allegations that he influenced Sophia's decisions and undermined the partnership. The saga serves as a cautionary tale about the potential consequences of mixing personal relationships with professional endeavors and the impact it can have on both parties involved.
The Impact and Legacy of a Podcast Scandal
The Call Her Daddy scandal reverberated through the podcasting industry and left a lasting impact on the hosts, media company, and listeners. The controversy highlighted the power dynamics and negotiations behind podcasting, shedding light on the challenges faced by creators in maintaining artistic control and fairness in contractual agreements. It also sparked wider discussions about gender dynamics, intellectual property rights, and the influence of podcasts in shaping cultural conversations. Despite the podcast's hiatus, the legacy of Call Her Daddy remains, as it continues to serve as a case study and cautionary tale about the complexities of navigating the business side of podcasting and the potential consequences of personal and professional conflicts.
They were two of the biggest names in podcasting. Together, Sofia Franklyn and Alex Cooper built a brand known around the world. But as fame, money, and attention came their way, the friendship that started it all completely crumbled.
This episode was researched by Eilish Gilligan and audio produced by Annabelle Lee.
Thanks to SBS On Demand for making this episode possible. Head to SBS On Demand to stream Erotic Stories for free now.
Got some thoughts on this scandal you wanna share? We’re allllll ears (also, eyes, heads, bodies, etc etc) - join in the convo over on our Insta @shamelesspodcast.
Want to support our show? We are sending air kisses, air tea, and air hugs (too far?) to anyone who clicks ‘subscribe’ on Apple (bonus hugs for anyone who leaves a five-star review, too) or ‘follow’ on Spotify.
Still not enough? Well! Our hearts! See below for everything else.
