The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Reaction to Bo Nix & Broncos OT win vs. Commanders on SNF + NFL Week 13
Dec 1, 2025
John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and insightful football analyst, shares his takes on a wild Week 13. He dives into Bo Nix's performance in the Broncos' OT win and critiques the Browns, calling their organization a mess despite talent. John also navigates the unpredictability of the NFC West, defends Steelers coach Mike Tomlin amid struggles, and discusses Lane Kiffin's controversial move to LSU. He wraps up with his Monday Night Football pick, emphasizing the evolving landscape of college scouting.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Broncos’ Extreme Upside And Downside
- John Middlekauff argues the Denver Broncos are the most volatile top-team in the NFL due to wildly inconsistent quarterback play and matchup-dependent defense.
- He believes their ceiling is Super Bowl contender but their floor is a first-round exit if Bo Nix plays poorly.
Bo Nix Is A Wild Card For Denver
- Middlekauff highlights Bo Nix as a giant wild card who alternates brilliant drives with poor errors that swing games.
- He says Sean Payton's reluctance to run the ball increases pressure on Nix and magnifies inconsistency.
AFC Is Wide Open And Messy
- The AFC is wide open with many contenders suffering injuries or inconsistency, making Denver a potential but uncertain favorite.
- Middlekauff sees no clear dominant team and calls the conference in 'complete shambles.'