This podcast explores the ineffable in Plotinus and his unique approach to the first principle. It discusses the esoteric nature of Platonist writing and the encounter with the one as a non-experience that defies reason and language. The concept of unsaying and apophatic discourse in Plotinus's works is analyzed, highlighting the denial of consciousness attributed to the one. The podcast also delves into different approaches to understanding Plotinus and his writing style, examining the concept of mysticism and its relation to philosophy.
Plotinus explores the ineffability of the one and its unsayability through performative apophatic texts.
Scholars acknowledge the necessity of leaving a blank, silent space in the interpretation of Plotinus's thought.
Deep dives
The Unsaying of the Real
Platinus engages in apophatic treatment of the first principle of reality, the one good. He positions the encounter with the one as an act of the esoteric, beyond the grasp of human language or thought. Platinus explores the ineffability of the one and its unsayability through performative apophatic texts. The encounter with the one is described as a profoundly beautiful and beyond beauty experience that cannot be articulated or comprehended through language or consciousness. Platinus circles around the unsayable and invites readers to transcend thought and enter a space of philosophic silence.
The Nature and Reasons for the Unsaying
The one is described as perfectly simple and without structure, surpassing the possibility of cognition or thought. Platinus argues that because all cognition involves parts, movement, or difference, it cannot grasp a being of true simplicity. The one's perfection and lack of dualism make it unthinkable and unsayable. Language, pertaining to the soul and cosmos, cannot express the nature of the one. Platinus offers logical deductions as reasons for the ineffability of the one, emphasizing the limitations of rational discourse and the human capacity to comprehend.
Interpreting Platinus's Unsaying
Scholars have approached Platinus's unsaying in various ways. Some see it as mysticism, others as the result of reconciling complex tradition, and some argue it stems from his own encounter with the one. Platinus's writing combines the genres of unsaying and initiatory secrets, emphasizing the esoteric nature of the encounter with the one. Interpretations range from considering Platinus as a mystic philosopher to exploring his unsaying as a performative poetic genre. Despite different interpretations, scholars acknowledge the necessity of leaving a blank, silent space in the interpretation of Platinus's thought.
The Esoteric Invitation
Platinus's esotericism aims to invite readers to become initiates, to experience the higher realities and the encounter with the one. He does not exclude but rather wants everyone to participate in the mysteries. Platinus's esotericism functions as a protreptic, summoning readers to transcend their normal way of thinking and cognition, and engage with the higher levels of reality beyond language and thought. This invitation creates a space of philosophic silence, allowing for the contemplation of the unsayable and the pursuit of the ineffable.
We discuss the ineffable in Plotinus: how it is deployed, how it is esoteric, how scholars have tried to deal with it, and how not least among its paradoxical functions is to call us to the highest initiation.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode