Intelligence Squared Debate: Is America a force for good in the world? Part 2
Nov 9, 2022
Shadi Hamid, a foreign policy expert, defends America’s positive role in the world, despite its complexities. Samuel Moyn counters with a critique, emphasizing that America’s actions often overshadow its good intentions. They discuss the implications of Trump's return on American exceptionalism and project a future world dominated by China. The dialogue highlights the delicate balance of U.S.-China relations, critiques the U.S. military legacy, and engages the audience on their perceptions of America's global influence.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Trump's Presidency vs. 9/11
- Shadi Hamid contrasts his experience during 9/11 with the Trump presidency.
- He felt relief that Trump's actions were less extreme than his rhetoric, citing the Muslim ban as an example.
America First
- Both U.S. political parties are leaning more towards "America First" policies.
- Biden's record is mixed, continuing some of Trump's policies, particularly regarding China.
European Dependence
- European power relies heavily on American military strength.
- This has allowed European countries to focus on welfare systems and economic interdependence, like Germany's Nord Stream pipeline.