The chilling case of the Lipstick Killer unfolds as a young girl's horrific murder in 1946 Chicago leads to shocking discoveries. An investigation grapples with ransom demands and witness testimonies, revealing the complexities behind one family's tragedy. As media frenzy surrounds the suspect, doubts about his confession emerge, highlighting issues of police misconduct. The narrative also connects this case to the infamous Black Dahlia murder, leaving listeners questioning the true nature of justice and the impact of sensational journalism.
The investigation into the 1946 murder of Suzanne Degnan reveals significant issues of police coercion and questionable evidence handling that compromised justice.
Contemporary reexaminations of the case raise doubts about the guilt of William Hirons and suggest the possibility of another suspect being involved.
Deep dives
The Disappearance of Suzanne Degnan
In January 1946, the tragic case of six-year-old Suzanne Degnan unfolded when her parents discovered she was missing from their Chicago home. After a frantic search led by her family and police, a ransom note was found, demanding $20,000, a sum well beyond the family's means. The recovery of a seven-foot ladder in their backyard suggested a planned abduction, which was corroborated by a neighbor's account of hearing Suzanne's voice amid dog barks during the night. Unfortunately, the search quickly turned into a gruesome investigation when Suzanne's dismembered remains were discovered in a nearby sewer, prompting a city-wide frenzy for answers and justice.
Investigative Challenges and Media Pressure
The investigation soon faced numerous challenges, as police struggled to find credible leads while being under intense media scrutiny. With large media outlets heavily covering the case, public pressure mounted on authorities to deliver quick results, often leading to issues with the integrity of the investigative process. Several suspects were arrested and interrogated under questionable practices, including coercive tactics that raised significant ethical concerns. The situation became increasingly complex as more evidence, including fingerprints and eyewitness testimonies, appeared inconclusive or unsubstantiated, creating a backdrop of confusion.
Arrest and Controversial Confessions
William Hirons, a 17-year-old who inadvertently became a suspect after an attempted burglary near the crime scene, was arrested and connected to the murders through questionable fingerprint evidence. His arrest led to a confession that he claimed was extracted under duress, as he had been mistreated during interrogation, including a controversial so-called truth serum injection. Even though he confessed, various aspects of the case, such as his psychiatric condition and the handling of evidence, raised doubts about the validity of his guilt. Compounding this issue was a troubling history of police coercion and manipulation that undermined the integrity of the evidence against Hirons.
Theoretical Controversies and Continuing Doubts
Over the years, questions arose regarding whether Hirons was framed or if someone else was the true culprit behind the infamous murders. Evidence emerged suggesting that another individual, Richard Russell Thomas, had confessed to Suzanne's murder well before Hirons became the prime suspect, but this line of inquiry was never thoroughly pursued by police. Moreover, contemporary theories began to emerge linking the case to well-known unsolved crimes, including the Black Dahlia murder, raising further speculation about the real identity of the killer. Despite a career marked by good behavior in prison and significant advocacy for his innocence, William Hirons passed away leaving lingering doubts about his conviction and whether justice had been served.
This episode was originally released in April 2020, and is one of sixteen episodes from the archives we'll be bringing you every Thursday now through end of year... for good reason! ;) We highly recommend you listen to each episode between now and end of 2024, and follow us on Instagram @crimejunkiepodcast so you're the first to know what's coming next! <3
A young Chicago girl’s brutal murder in 1946 led police to a dangerous criminal with more blood on his hands than anyone could have imagined. However, decades later, those who re-examine the facts wonder if they got the wrong man.
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.