Make America Male Again? Fifteen years of aggrieved men
Nov 19, 2024
auto_awesome
Hanna Rosin, author of 'The End of Men' and host of Radio Atlantic, dives deep into the crisis facing modern men. She discusses how changing gender dynamics have left many men feeling lost and aggrieved, connected to broader political movements. The conversation highlights individual struggles, like that of Luke, a divorced man dealing with societal pressures. Rosin also explores the tension between traditional and progressive gender roles, emphasizing the critical need for redefined identities and greater emotional intelligence in navigating these shifts.
The podcast highlights that men are increasingly falling behind in education and employment, leading to significant gender disparities in success.
Cultural shifts have left many men feeling dislocated and anxious, resulting in political movements that yearn for a return to traditional values.
Deep dives
Gender Disparities in Success
Recent trends indicate that men are increasingly falling behind women in various measures of success, a situation that Hannah Rosen first highlighted in her book, The End of Men. The conversation reveals that in educational settings, the majority of high achievers are girls, whereas boys are more frequently underperforming, illustrating a significant gender gap that has persisted over time. As traditional job markets diminish and wages stagnate, men are facing unique challenges that contribute to their struggles in contemporary society. This pattern is complicated by cultural narratives that have centered around women breaking glass ceilings, which has overshadowed the urgent need to address the difficulties boys and men are encountering.
Cultural Shifts and Gender Roles
The podcast explores the evolution of gender roles and how societal changes have left many men feeling dislocated, struggling to find their identity in a rapidly changing world. While women have adapted to shifting expectations—balancing careers, education, and family—many men feel unmoored without the traditional roles of provider or husband. This cultural stagnation has led to increased anxieties among men, often manifesting in aggressive political movements and a longing for a perceived stability of the past. By examining the composite character 'Luke,' whom many men can relate to, the discussion illustrates how the frustrations and fears of modern manhood have become increasingly vocal and connected to broader societal shifts.
Seeking Stability in a Changing World
Underlying the anxieties each gender faces is a shared experience of instability, prompting divergent approaches to finding solutions. Some individuals yearn for a return to the past, seeking stability in traditional values, while others embrace a more flexible understanding of self-identity. This illustrates a significant cultural divide, with one side clinging to rigid gender norms while the other strives for self-determination amidst chaos. Ultimately, the discussion raises critical questions about how society can navigate these complex dynamics and redefine gender roles to foster an environment where both men and women can thrive.
The boys are not alright. They are falling behind in education and employment, and many have responded by leaning into the politics of the aggrieved. For decades, these major cultural developments have laid the groundwork for Donald Trump's re-election.
Today Brittany talks with Hanna Rosin. Fifteen years ago she started researching what was going on with men. Her groundbreaking book The End of Men was one of the first to note this societal shift for men. Over a decade later, her assessment is more accurate than ever.