My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 462
Nov 17, 2025
This minisode dives into the chilling theme of creepy neighbors. One story unfolds about a college neighbor who left eerie gifts, later revealed to be running a meth lab. Another shocking tale involves a grumpy neighbor turning out to be the Golden State Killer. Listeners share hair-raising encounters, including an unsolicited love note and a protective dog scaring off a disturbing neighbor. One hilarious yet spooky anecdote involves a voodoo doll accidentally cursing a neighbor. Get ready for a blend of fright and humor!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Creepy Neighbor Turned Out To Run A Meth Lab
- A college student lived next to a creepy tenant who claimed to be a virgin and left cigarette-butt-filled flowerpots and notes.
- SWAT and DEA later raided his unit and discovered a meth lab, prompting the student to transfer schools.
Sister Lived Near The Golden State Killer
- A woman discovered that her sister once lived less than ten houses from Joseph DeAngelo, the Golden State Killer.
- The sister had been creeped out by his yard-trimming, yelling, and odd behavior years earlier.
Unsigned Note Led To Confrontation With Renter
- A 22-year-old found a complimentary, unsigned note on her car and later confronted the likely author, a nearby renter who then asked her to hang out.
- She told the restaurant staff and the bartender intervened, after which he avoided her.