Markets are Good for More than Wealth (w/ Tom Palmer)
Mar 1, 2025
auto_awesome
In this discussion, Tom Palmer, Executive Vice President for International Programs at Atlas Network and Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute, argues that markets do more than generate wealth—they can also enhance our moral character. He challenges common criticisms that markets foster selfishness, instead showcasing how they promote cooperation and ethical interactions. Drawing on personal stories from Guatemala, he illustrates the positive dynamics of market exchanges, revealing the camaraderie and mutual benefits that arise when individuals collaborate.
Markets foster moral virtues by promoting empathy and understanding among individuals through voluntary exchanges, enhancing human character beyond mere economic wealth.
While critics argue that markets encourage greed, historical evidence shows that economic growth from market activities often leads to greater ethical awareness and humanitarian movements.
Deep dives
The Moral Case for Markets
Markets are often viewed solely through an economic lens, but they also have significant moral and ethical implications. Advocates argue that rather than promoting selfishness and greed, markets can actually enhance human virtues and make individuals better people. They challenge the notion that markets corrupt moral character, suggesting that real-life conflicts and unethical behaviors exist even in non-market societies. This argument posits that voluntary exchanges foster moral virtues by encouraging understanding and empathy among participants.
The Distinction Between Market Behaviors
Critics often focus on how markets may encourage undesirable traits like greed or dishonesty, suggesting that market activities, such as buying and selling, are inherently immoral. However, this perspective overlooks the context in which exchanges occur and the intentions behind them. In many cases, market interactions resemble cooperation, where individuals seek mutual benefits rather than exploiting one another. Such interactions can be compared to team dynamics, where individual success contributes to collective achievements without harming others.
Market Exchange and Empathy
Engaging in market exchanges encourages individuals to consider the needs and desires of others, fostering a greater moral consciousness. Understanding customer preferences, for example, requires putting oneself in another's shoes, which builds empathy and compassion. Historical evidence shows that the most significant humanitarian movements, such as the abolition of slavery, often arose in wealthy, market-oriented societies. Therefore, as people become wealthier through market interactions, they tend to develop a deeper care for ethical treatment, including that of animals and other marginalized groups.
The Misunderstood Nature of Wants
Critics of market economies argue that they create artificial wants and foster consumerism, yet this view misrepresents the growth of individual desires as a natural aspect of development. Humanity has always pursued new experiences and pleasures, and markets merely provide the means for these explorations. Furthermore, the idea that markets lead to addiction or compulsive consumption often disregards instances where individuals freely make choices about their preferences. Ultimately, acknowledging the agency of consumers reveals that concerns about manufactured wants are less about market dynamics and more about human nature.
We talk a lot on this show about the benefits of free and open markets and, given the growing hostility to economic freedom, not just from the Trump administration, but from populist governments around the world, we'll continue to do so.
Today I wanted to approach that conversation a little differently from usual though. Most of the time, when people say markets are good, what they mean is that markets make us richer, driven innovation, and so on. But markets do more than that. They make us better people, too.
This is a controversial claim, because so many criticisms of markets will admit that they create wealth, but then chastise them for promoting selfishness and greed, or replacing cooperation with callous competition.
That's wrong, however. And to discuss why, and why markets aren't just economically better, but morally bettering, as well, I've brought back my good friend Tom Palmer. He is executive vice president for international programs at Atlas Network, where he holds the George M. Yeager Chair for Advancing Liberty, and a Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute.
If you enjoy ReImagining Liberty and want to listen to episodes free of ads and sponsorships, become a supporter. Learn more here: https://www.aaronrosspowell.com/upgrade
I also encourage you to check out my companion newsletter, where I write about the kinds of ideas we discuss on this show. You can find it on my website at www.aaronrosspowell.com.