Jeff Mikels, a pastor with over twenty years of experience, dives into the infiltration of political idols within evangelicalism. He shares his personal journey confronting division in the church, especially during the Trump presidency. Mikels discusses the dangers of conflating faith with conservative politics, addressing the misconception of America as a Christian nation and the harmful beliefs surrounding wealth as divine favor. Emphasizing a return to gospel-centered unity, he encourages thoughtful Christian activism that embodies core values of compassion.
Pastor Jeff Mikels highlights the significant infiltration of political and cultural idols within modern evangelicalism, leading to division and the distortion of faith.
The podcast emphasizes the essential need for church leaders to prioritize gospel-centered faith over political allegiance to foster unity within congregations.
Mikels advocates for a redefined approach to Christian activism that genuinely embodies gospel values while effectively engaging the broader culture.
Deep dives
Pastor Jeff Michaels' Background and Mission
Pastor Jeff Michaels, an evangelical leader with over two decades of ministry experience, focuses on the issues of idolatry within evangelicalism. He emphasizes how political and cultural idols have infiltrated the faith, largely with the complicity of church leaders. His background as a church planter and president of the Greater Lafayette Gospel Association informs his mission to promote unity among churches rather than division. In his book, 'Evangelical Idolatry', he calls for a return to a gospel-centered faith, highlighting the need for reform within evangelical practices.
Impact of Political Polarization on the Church
The rise of political polarization, especially during the Trump era, is discussed as a catalyst for church division. Michaels shares his firsthand experiences of ostracism from fellow congregations after his church followed COVID-19 lockdown guidelines, contrasting it with a previously about 10 years of collaboration with other churches. This division became clearer as conservative evangelicals were drawn to political figures, often at the expense of community and biblical principles. The situation illustrates the urgent need for church leaders to navigate the challenging intersection of faith and politics without compromising their doctrines.
Challenges of Pastoral Identity amid Cultural Turmoil
Michaels reflects on the challenge pastors face in maintaining their integrity and pastoral identity amidst a culture that often emphasizes political allegiance over faith. He recounts a personal crisis when his stance on social justice issues and his concern for racial equality led to significant backlash from his congregation. This phenomenon, where congregational loyalty becomes tied to political ideologies, highlights the difficult position many pastors find themselves in. The need for a community that values gospel truth over cultural narratives is emphasized as critical for future church health.
The Dangers of Idolatry in Evangelicalism
In discussing idolatry, Michaels argues that contemporary evangelicalism often conflates political ideology with biblical theology, creating dangerous idols that distract from true faith. He identifies the idol of 'blessing', which equates material success with divine approval, as a profound misconception within the church. This entanglement of faith with cultural success creates a narrative that can lead to justifying morally dubious political actions in the name of God. The need for a deep introspection concerning what constitutes true blessings and the potential idols that may form in their place is underscored.
A Call for Reformed Christian Activism
Michaels advocates for a redefined approach to Christian activism that aligns with gospel values rather than cultural or political pressures. He suggests that understanding the nature of the gospel—both as a belief and a way of living—is vital for effective activism in a pluralistic society. The translation of Christian values into non-Christian contexts is positioned as an essential method to engage the broader culture authentically. Ultimately, Michaels stresses the importance of an activism rooted in a profound understanding of scripture and a commitment to love and serve neighbors, rather than adhering to partisan lines.
In this episode of Faithful Politics, Pastor Jeff Mikels discusses his book 'Evangelical Idolatry' and reflects on how political and cultural idols have infiltrated evangelicalism. He shares his personal journey of realizing the division within the church and the challenges he faced when he spoke out against the Trump presidency. Michaels explores the deeper issues within American evangelicalism, including fear as a motivator and the conservative mindset. He emphasizes the need for pastors and congregants to return to a gospel-centered faith and promote unity within the church. In this conversation, Jeff Mikels discusses the blending of faith and politics in evangelicalism and the dangers of idolatry. He explores the idea that conservative evangelicalism often confuses conservative political ideology with divine inspiration, leading to the idolization of certain political figures. He also addresses the notion of America as a Christian nation and the problematic belief that success and wealth are signs of God's blessing. Mikels emphasizes the need for Christians to understand the gospel as both a belief and a way of life, and to translate Christian values to the non-Christian world through proper Christian activism.
Pre-Order the book: https://a.co/d/7WgmLa0
Guest Bio: Jeff Mikels holds degrees from Wheaton College and Denver Seminary. He has over twenty years of pastoral experience, leading a church in Chicago for five years before planting one in Lafayette, Indiana. There, he was involved in the Pastors’ Alliance; he also helped establish the Greater Lafayette Gospel Association, which is a network of gospel-focused ministries, and served as its president.
