The Counsel of Trent

#1105 - The Moral Madness of Atheism

25 snips
Dec 8, 2025
Trent explores the intricacies of moral arguments for God's existence, dissecting various secular alternatives to morality. He highlights C.S. Lewis's insights on moral law and the challenges atheistic frameworks face in grounding concepts of right and wrong. The podcast dives into the perplexing nature of human versus animal value, sexual ethics, and the implications of potentiality. Trent provocatively invites atheists to reflect on ethical dilemmas, ultimately framing God as essential for a coherent moral landscape.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Objective Morality, Not Mere Goodness

  • The moral argument doesn't claim belief is needed to act morally but that objective morality requires God.
  • Focus on objective moral truths, not personal conduct, to make the case persuasive.
ANECDOTE

Lewis's Bus-Seat Example

  • C.S. Lewis used everyday disputes, like who gets a bus seat, to show people appeal to a moral standard beyond opinion.
  • Lewis argued cultural disagreement supports objective morality because they can be truer or less true.
INSIGHT

Atheist Alternatives To Divine Morality

  • Even if objective moral truths exist, atheists offer alternative explanations like Platonism or necessary moral truths.
  • Philosophers such as Eric Wielenberg propose brute necessary moral truths without God.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app