The New Statesman: politics and culture Labour's deja vu problem
Oct 9, 2025
In this discussion, Andrew Marr, a seasoned political journalist and the political editor for the New Statesman, joins Tom McTague to dive into Labour's current landscape. They explore Shabana Mahmood's ambitious plans to reform migration laws and the internal clashes within Keir Starmer's team. Marr analyzes the influence of Blair-era figures on today's politics and reflects on the nostalgic allure of those years. The conversation also tackles Britain's geopolitical stance, the tension between migration policy and progressive values, and the role of seasoned operatives in contemporary governance.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Mahmood's Hardline Rights Reform
- Shabana Mahmood has a radical plan to reshape ECHR Articles 3 and 8 and the Refugee Convention to cut migration numbers.
- Andrew Marr warns this will ignite a fierce row within Labour over human-rights reform.
Judicial Constraints And Populist Pressure
- The government argues judges misuse Articles 3 and 8 to block removals and privilege migrants over citizens.
- Marr says many European governments now feel similar pressure and fear a populist backlash if they do nothing.
Avoid Mixed Messaging On Immigration
- Labour must choose between winning border-sceptic voters with tougher measures or condemning Farage while mimicking his policies.
- You cannot credibly vilify a politician and simultaneously adopt their agenda, Marr argues.
