Stephen Richer, an election official from Arizona, and Adam Kinzinger, a former Republican congressman, engage in a compelling discussion on the insidious spread of conspiracy theories affecting democracy. They delve into personal experiences with political absurdities and the erosion of truth, revealing how unfounded claims can corrode trust in electoral processes. The conversation highlights the psychological toll on public officials and the pressures to conform within party lines, drawing alarming parallels to authoritarian regimes.
The rise of conspiracy theories undermines factual discourse, fostering an environment where political loyalty is prioritized over democratic ideals.
The psychological impact on individuals who resist conformism leads to fear and ostracism, reflecting a dangerous division within political communities.
Deep dives
Valley Forge: A Symbol of Democracy's Fragility
At Valley Forge in 1778, George Washington's officers performed the play Cato, highlighting the historical concerns over democracy and dictatorship. The choice of this play signifies the Founders' fears about democracy being threatened by autocratic power grabs, as depicted in Cato's story about the fall of the Roman Republic. The podcast emphasizes how each generation perceives threats to democracy, often drawing parallels between past and present political climates. Currently, sentiments of rising authoritarianism and the degradation of democratic principles are echoed in contemporary discussions surrounding political discourse in America.
The Dangers of Political Apathy and Conspiracies
The episode discusses how widening political apathy and the rise of conspiracy theories lay the groundwork for authoritarianism. Personal reflections reveal that conspiracy theories like birtherism have gained traction in America, mirroring experiences in countries that have slipped into autocracy. The acceptance of such conspiratorial narratives undermines factual discourse, leading to a culture where evidence is disregarded in favor of group loyalty. This dangerous trend reinforces the idea that for some, political affiliation is signified more by adherence to falsehoods than by commitment to democratic ideals.
Absurd Accusations and the Erosion of Trust
The narrative delves into the absurdity of accusations against election officials, as exemplified by Arizona's Stephen Richard, who faced baseless claims from prominent political figures. These wild accusations not only impact the individuals targeted but also instill fear and uncertainty within democratic systems. The absurdity of such claims creates an environment where independent facts are malleable, making it nearly impossible for targeted individuals to defend themselves against these political machinations. This situation reflects a significant erosion of trust in electoral integrity and the institutions that uphold democracy.
The Psychological Cost of Political Division
The conversation investigates the psychological toll taken on individuals who challenge the prevailing narratives within their political groups, illustrated by Adam Kinzinger's experience. Those who strive to maintain integrity often face ostracism, threats, and severe backlash from their peers, creating a climate of fear and intimidation. Kinzinger's anecdote about a friend’s hostile reaction showcases the fracturing of relationships based on political beliefs, leading to an environment where party loyalty supersedes personal connections. This division highlights the broader consequences of a political culture increasingly devoid of a shared reality, where emotional responses dominate rational debate.
The corruption of democracy begins with the corruption of thought—and with the deliberate undermining of reality. Stephen Richer, an election official in Arizona, and Adam Kinzinger, a former Republican congressman, learned firsthand how easily false stories and conspiracy theories could disorient their colleagues. They talk with hosts Anne Applebaum and Peter Pomerantsev about how conformism and fear made it impossible to do their jobs.
Autocracy in America is produced by The Atlantic and made possible with support from the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University, an academic and public forum dedicated to strengthening global democracy through powerful civic engagement and informed, inclusive dialogue.
Music by ELFL (“The Flux Beneath it All”), Skrya (“Mysterious Ways”), Howard Harper-Barnes (“Mysterious Forest”), J. F. Gloss (“Mysterious Figures”), Mary Riddle (“Go Lions,” “A United Nation”), Medité (“A Mysterious Lady”), Cercles Nouvelles (“Ancient Rome”), and Rob Smierciak (“Mystery March”).
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.