A shocking discovery in a New York basement unveils the remains of Patricia McGlone, a young woman identified after decades. The investigation reveals layers of deceit in her family and uncovers connections to a suspected serial killer. As detectives navigate forensic challenges, the story intertwines with personal tales of loss and leaves listeners with a powerful call to action. Additionally, explore the bizarre links between daylight saving time and burglary, and how personal journeys can inspire advocacy for safety and justice.
The discovery of a young woman's remains in a concrete tomb highlights the calculated nature of her murder, raising urgent questions about her fate.
Forensic analysis unveiled critical clues about Patricia McGlone's past, revealing contrasting indicators of her social connections and health background.
Advancements in genetic genealogy finally led to the identification of Patricia McGlone after decades, yet her killer remains unidentified.
Deep dives
Gruesome Discovery and Initial Investigation
Construction workers in Midtown Manhattan made a horrifying discovery when they uncovered a concrete slab while clearing debris. Upon breaking it apart, they found a human skull and skeletal remains encased in a rusty carpet, suggesting foul play. Detective Gerard Gardner quickly deemed the case a homicide due to signs of trauma, including the victim being hogtied with an electrical cord. The initial findings indicated the victim was a young woman, aged between 15 and 21, prompting a comprehensive investigation to identify her.
Building a Profile of the Victim
Forensic analysis revealed that the victim had long fingernails, indicating possible care and grooming, while jewelry found on her suggested she had some social connections. With expensive dental work on her back teeth but decay on her front teeth, investigators hypothesized that she may have come from a background that supported her health initially, but had since deteriorated. Given the location and circumstances surrounding her death, they theorized that she could have been a runaway from the Midwest, drawn to the dangerous environment of Hell's Kitchen known for drugs and exploitation. This led them to cautiously consider her as a victim of abduction or human trafficking.
The Challenge of Identification
Despite efforts to uncover the identity of the victim, including comparisons of jewelry and dental records, the process faced numerous hurdles. Initial leads centered around initials found on a signet ring, potentially pointing to various missing persons across the country, but all attempts yielded dead ends. Additionally, forensic samples were degrading, complicating DNA analyses and hindering matching procedures. Investigators uncovered familial connections but struggled with how to proceed without concrete evidence linking them to the remains.
Revisiting Key Suspects and Evidence
As the investigation teams turned to historical records, a notorious serial killer, Joel Rifkin, emerged as a suspect due to his MO of targeting vulnerable women, although there were no direct links found between him and the victim. Detective Gardner attempted to build connections based on the timeline of events, but they were often thwarted by the lack of individuals who could provide insight into the victim's life. Meanwhile, soil evidence unearthed clues but remained inconclusive as to the precise time and circumstances of her death. The case languished with many details lost in time, yet new methods of investigation began to emerge.
Breakthroughs with Genetic Genealogy
The case saw a revival with advances in genetic genealogy, enabling detectives to explore familial connections through DNA evidence extracted from the remains. After a lengthy process, they identified a first cousin, leading to crucial discoveries about the victim's identity, revealing her as Patricia McGlone. Historical discrepancies and family secrets unfolded, exposing a convoluted family dynamic marked by deception, and revealing that Patricia's life was marred by instability and absence. While Patricia's identity was confirmed, the search for her killer continued, as investigators sought to piece together the events leading to her tragic demise and the mysterious circumstances surrounding her marriage to an unknown man.
In 2003, construction workers in Hell’s Kitchen, New York, discovered a concrete tomb hidden in the basement of a run-down building. Inside were the remains of a young woman, hogtied with pantyhose and electrical cords, this gruesome scene was more than shocking—it was deeply calculated. It took more than two decades for investigators to identify her as 16-year-old Patricia McGlone, who was last seen in 1969. But despite finally giving her a name, her killer remains at large. Now, police are asking for your help to find the person responsible and bring Patricia the justice she’s been denied for far too long.
If you know anything about Patricia McGlone or the circumstances of her murder, please contact Crime Stoppers at 1-800-577-TIPS.
Patricia’s childhood home was located at 375 52nd Street in Brooklyn, New York. She went to the following schools:
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.
The Crime Junkie Merch Store is NOW OPEN! Shop the exclusive Life Rule #10 Tour collection before it’s gone for good! Don’t miss your chance - visit the store now!
