The Case for Competition

24 snips

Dec 18, 2024

Greg Lukianoff, President and CEO of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, dives into the erosion of free speech in America and its implications on college campuses. He discusses the tension between defamation and free expression amidst today’s disinformation challenges, while also reflecting on Elon Musk's Twitter takeover and its impact on discourse. The conversation highlights the essential role of competition in political discussion and the need for reforms in higher education to foster critical thinking. A must-listen for anyone passionate about free speech!

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Free Speech Health

Free speech is increasingly upheld by centrists, leaving both extremes vulnerable.
The health of free speech is declining, especially on college campuses and internationally.

INSIGHT

Declining Free Speech Culture

Free speech culture has declined, with fewer people believing in the right to hold different opinions.
The current attacks on Jesse Singal exemplify this decline.

ANECDOTE

Trump and Media

Trump's administration discussed suing media outlets, causing concern for free speech advocates.
The ABC News settlement with Trump over a false statement, while not a legal victory for Trump, raises concerns about intimidation.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Nietzsche

Friedrich Nietzsche

The Constitution of Knowledge

Jonathan Rauch

scale

This sound

Jeffrey West

The novel centers on two Chinese American siblings on the lam after their sometimes abusive father dies, leaving them to survive in a dreamscape that blends historical and mythological elements. The story is narrated by a sister whose gender is more fluid and includes elements of ghost narratives, gold, and tigers. Zhang's work challenges the traditional white-centered narratives of the American West, incorporating elements of her own cultural background and childhood experiences.

Power

Why Some People Have It—and Others Don’t

Jeffrey Pfeffer

In this book, Jeffrey Pfeffer provides insightful and often counterintuitive advice on how power is successfully built and maintained in organizations. Drawing from his extensive experience in consulting and teaching, Pfeffer argues that power is not just for a select few but can be harnessed by anyone. The book dispels the myth that power is only for those in charge and instead reveals the true paths to career success, emphasizing the importance of personal networks, reputation, and effective social interactions. Pfeffer uses numerous examples from various countries and industries to illustrate his points, making the book an essential organizational survival manual and a new standard in the field of leadership and management.

Suicide of the west

How the Rebirth of Tribalism, Populism, Nationalism, and Identity Politics Is Destroying American Democracy

Jonah Goldberg

In 'Suicide of the West,' Jonah Goldberg argues that the principles of liberal democracy and capitalism, which he terms 'the Miracle,' are under threat from various forms of illiberalism. He contends that the West's prosperity and political stability are not inevitable but rather the result of unique historical and philosophical developments. Goldberg warns that complacency and the erosion of these principles due to partisanship, polarization, and identity politics could lead to democratic decline. He emphasizes the importance of gratitude for the achievements of Western civilization and the need to rediscover and uphold its founding ideals to prevent its downfall.

The Population Bomb

Anne H. Ehrlich

Paul Ehrlich

Published in 1968, 'The Population Bomb' by Paul and Anne Ehrlich predicts catastrophic consequences, including mass starvation and environmental ruin, due to unchecked population growth. The book argues that immediate action is necessary to control population growth to prevent these dire outcomes. Although many of the Ehrlichs' predictions did not come to pass, the book significantly raised awareness about population and environmental issues and influenced public policy in the 1960s and 1970s. The authors emphasize the need for conscious regulation of human numbers and highlight the strain that growing populations place on the natural world[1][4][5].

Kendi

Ibram X Kendi

Locke

John Locke

In this monumental work, Locke defends modern empiricism and examines the sources and nature of human knowledge. The essay is divided into four books, where Locke argues that there is no innate knowledge, and all ideas come from experience through sensation and reflection. He also discusses the distinction between primary and secondary qualities of physical objects and the concept of personal identity as a continuity of consciousness[1][3][5].

Repressive Tolerance

Herbert Marcuse

The Coddling of the American Mind

Jonathan Haidt

Greg Lukianoff

The book explores how the ideas 'what doesn’t kill you makes you weaker,' 'always trust your feelings,' and 'life is a battle between good people and evil people' have become embedded in American culture. These 'Great Untruths' contradict basic psychological principles and ancient wisdom, leading to a culture of safetyism that interferes with young people’s social, emotional, and intellectual development. The authors investigate various social trends, including fearful parenting, the decline of unsupervised play, and the impact of social media, as well as changes on college campuses and the broader context of political polarization in America.

Rousseau

Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Freedom from speech

Greg Lukianoff

In this book, Greg Lukianoff argues that the threats to free speech extend beyond political correctness or liberal groupthink. He discusses how global populations are increasingly expecting not just physical but also intellectual comfort, leading to heightened demands for 'freedom from speech.' Lukianoff emphasizes the need to understand and combat this trend to protect free speech, especially in academic environments where it is already in decline.

The Wealth of Nations

Adam Smith

Published in 1776, 'The Wealth of Nations' is Adam Smith's magnum opus that laid the groundwork for modern economics. The book critiques mercantilist economic theories and introduces the concept of the 'invisible hand,' which describes how individual self-interest leads to societal benefit. It emphasizes the division of labor, the accumulation of capital, and the importance of free markets. Smith argues that a nation's wealth is not measured by its gold and silver reserves but by the stream of goods and services it produces. The book also outlines the core functions of government, such as maintaining defense, enforcing civil law, and promoting education, while advocating for limited government intervention in market activities.

Hume

David Hume

Unlearning liberty

Campus Censorship and the End of American Debate

Greg Lukianoff

In 'Unlearning Liberty: Campus Censorship and the End of American Debate,' Greg Lukianoff examines the decline of free speech on American college campuses. The book argues that decades of campus censorship have contributed to a culture of hyperpolarization and groupthink, undermining the essential principles of academic freedom and open debate. Lukianoff discusses how the therapeutic turn in society, which emphasizes the vulnerability of individuals, has justified censorship as a means to protect students from hurtful words and opinions. He also highlights the historical importance of free speech in academic life and its current erosion, which he believes threatens the broader American discourse.

American Covenant

How the Constitution Unified Our Nation—and Could Again

Yuval Levin

In 'American Covenant,' Yuval Levin argues that the U.S. Constitution is not the source of contemporary political discord but rather the solution. The book blends historical analysis with practical insights, highlighting the framers’ sophisticated understanding of political division and the Constitution’s power to facilitate constructive disagreement and forge unity. Levin provides a hopeful and insightful perspective, rooted in American political tradition, and offers practical solutions for reforming aspects of the constitutional order that have malfunctioned.

Vixi

Memoirs of a Non-Believer

Richard Edgar Pipes

In 'Vixi: Memoirs of a Non-Believer,' Richard Pipes reflects on his life, from his escape from Nazi-occupied Poland to his distinguished career as a historian of Russian and Soviet history. The book covers his academic achievements, his role in shaping U.S. policy towards the Soviet Union, and his personal philosophy. Pipes recounts his experiences at Harvard University, his involvement with the National Security Council, and his critiques of communism and the Soviet regime.

FIRE's guide to free speech on campus

Greg Lukianoff

Harvey Silverglate

David A. French

First published in 2005 and updated in 2012, FIRE's Guide to Free Speech on Campus informs students about their rights to free speech and provides strategies for combating censorship on campus. The guide is particularly relevant in the era of social media and the internet, offering examples from FIRE's case archives, updates on state and federal case law, and incisive analysis. It aims to empower students to defend their civil liberties and promote a culture of free expression on college campuses.

The Promise of America

Harvey Kaye

The greening of America

Charles A Reich

Published in 1970, 'The Greening of America' is a seminal work that captures the essence of the counterculture movement. The book introduces a typology of three types of consciousness: Consciousness I (village life), Consciousness II (Corporate State), and Consciousness III (a radical, idealistic new consciousness). Reich argues that social and political change must begin with individual transformation, leading to cultural and eventually systemic change. The book was widely discussed and debated upon its release, reflecting the societal upheavals of the time.

Words That Wound

Richard Delgado

Kimberle Crenshaw

Lawrence, Charles

Mari J. Matsuda

In this book, four prominent legal scholars from the tradition of critical race theory draw on the experience of injury from racist hate speech to develop a First Amendment interpretation that recognizes such injuries. The authors critique 'first amendment orthodoxy' and argue that only a history of racism can explain why defamation, invasion of privacy, and fraud are exempt from free-speech guarantees while racist and sexist verbal assaults are not. The book demonstrates how critical race theory can be used to motivate a responsible regulation of hate speech, also incorporating insights from feminist theory.