Intelligence Squared The Sunday Debate: The Northern Ireland Question: Is it Time to Abandon The Protocol?
Jun 26, 2022
Jill Rutter, a Brexit expert, delves into the complexities of the Northern Ireland Protocol and its historical context. Claire Hanna, MP for South Belfast, provides the nationalist viewpoint, discussing the protocol's implications for peace and stability. Darren McCaffrey shares insights on political dynamics in Northern Ireland, emphasizing the need for compromise amidst ongoing tensions. The conversation highlights the challenges of balancing UK-EU relations while addressing local concerns and the potential impact on the region's future.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Unilateral Action Concerns
- The UK government's new bill to change the Northern Ireland Protocol is surprisingly broad and disruptive.
- It raises concerns about the government's commitment to negotiated settlements and has been met with disapproval from many in Northern Ireland.
Trust and Brexit
- The UK government's actions regarding the Northern Ireland Protocol raise trust issues with the EU.
- The UK's justification, that they didn't understand the implications, is weak, as impact assessments clearly outlined potential challenges.
May vs. Johnson Brexit Approaches
- Theresa May's Brexit backstop was a temporary measure pending future negotiations.
- Boris Johnson's decision to finalize the Northern Ireland trade regime prematurely contributed to a harder Brexit and deeper divisions.