The Atlas Obscura Podcast The Manhattan Well with Lauren Willig
8 snips
Apr 17, 2025 Joining Dylan is Lauren Willig, a former lawyer and prolific historical fiction author. She dives into the chilling tale of Elma Sands, the first recorded murder trial in the U.S., featuring notorious figures like Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr. Their courtroom drama unfolds against the backdrop of late 18th century New York, revealing societal norms and hidden truths. Lauren also shares insights from her latest novel, which brings to life the intrigue and complexity of this fascinating case.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Elma Sands' Mysterious Death
- Elma Sands disappeared on December 22, 1799, and her body was found in the Manhattan Well two weeks later.
- Levi Weeks, a young carpenter, was quickly accused of her murder, sparking a sensational case.
Murder Motive Challenges Rumors
- The popular motive was that Levi Weeks seduced Elma Sands, got her pregnant, then rejected her for a more prosperous marriage.
- However, coroner's inquest found Elma was not pregnant, challenging this rumor.
The Well's Intriguing Business Link
- The Manhattan Well was built as part of Aaron Burr's Manhattan Company water scheme funded by the surplus revenue, with Ezra Weeks as contractor.
- This connects the murder site directly to the legal defense team through business ties.
