The Atlas Obscura Podcast
The Manhattan Well with Lauren Willig
Apr 17, 2025
Joining Dylan is Lauren Willig, a former lawyer and prolific historical fiction author. She dives into the chilling tale of Elma Sands, the first recorded murder trial in the U.S., featuring notorious figures like Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr. Their courtroom drama unfolds against the backdrop of late 18th century New York, revealing societal norms and hidden truths. Lauren also shares insights from her latest novel, which brings to life the intrigue and complexity of this fascinating case.
27:39
Episode guests
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- The Manhattan Well case is significant as it marks the first recorded murder trial in U.S. history, involving high-profile lawyers like Hamilton and Burr.
- The trial underscored societal norms of the era, showcasing public fascination with crime and the contrasting legal strategies employed by its renowned defenders.
Deep dives
The Infamous Murder Case of Elma Sands
Elma Sands disappeared on December 22, 1799, shortly before her body was found in the Manhattan Well two weeks later. Levi Weeks, a young carpenter, became the prime suspect in her murder when the well's mystery unraveled, leading to intense public scrutiny. The circumstances surrounding her death raised many questions, especially regarding her relationship with Levi and rumors of a secret elopement. The case gained notoriety as it became the first fully recorded murder trial in American history, drawing attention from influential figures like Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
