David Deutsch, a pioneering quantum physicist known for his insights into quantum computation and the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, joins the conversation. They delve into the complexities of quantum mechanics, including the implications of Schrödinger's cat and multiverse theory. Deutsch shares his thoughts on quantum computing's future and AI developments, while also tackling deeper issues like antisemitism and the historical context surrounding Israel. The dialogue navigates fascinating intersections of science, philosophy, and societal challenges.
The many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics proposes that all possible outcomes exist simultaneously across parallel universes, reshaping our understanding of reality.
The discussion around scientific interpretations, like those in quantum mechanics, reveals the dangers of treating unfounded views as valid in the pursuit of objective truth.
Deep dives
The Many Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics
The many worlds interpretation, proposed by Hugh Everett, suggests that quantum reality consists of numerous parallel universes that arise from quantum events. Unlike traditional views that perceive quantum mechanics as a calculation tool without rooting meaning in reality, this interpretation posits that every possible outcome of a quantum event occurs in its own universe. The multiverse concept implies that when an experiment is conducted, observers exist in a superposition of states, thus splitting into multiple versions as outcomes materialize. This framework challenges conventional thinking, particularly the notion of wave function collapse that relies on observation, and instead argues for the existence of many coexisting realities where different outcomes happen simultaneously.
Critique of Interpretation in Science
The ongoing debate over interpretations of quantum mechanics highlights a significant criticism of how scientific theories are often perceived. Many physicists treat interpretations as equally valid, which can lead to misunderstanding the objective nature of scientific inquiry. This laxity resembles historical disagreements about the existence of dinosaurs, where creationist views conflicted with established scientific evidence, yet were not dismissed convincingly. This analogy illustrates that allowing unfounded interpretations to coexist with scientifically rigorous theories can distort our understanding of reality and progress in physics.
The Role of Observation and Consciousness
Traditionally, the observation of quantum states has been seen as pivotal in determining their existence in a definite state, leading to questions about the role of consciousness in wave function collapse. This contention simplifies the complex nature of reality, suggesting that something external, like the act of observation or consciousness, is essential for defining states. The many worlds interpretation bypasses this by asserting that universes split as interactions occur, eliminating the need for an observer's consciousness to dictate reality. Consequently, this perspective encourages a reconsideration of probability in quantum mechanics, as all possible outcomes actually exist, fundamentally reshaping our understanding of possibility in the universe.
Sam Harris speaks with David Deutsch about quantum physics and current events. They discuss the “many-worlds” interpretation of QM, Schrödinger’s cat, constructor theory, quantum computing and whether it will ever be practically possible, recent developments in AI, the prospects of artificial super-intelligence, the alignment problem, antisemitism and the historical persecution of Jews, misconceptions about Israel, the future of the Jews in Israel and the West, and other topics.
If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
