Making the Argument with Nick Freitas What Should The Right Want? w/ Michael Knowles
Jan 1, 2026
Michael Knowles, a conservative commentator and author, discusses the current divisions within the Right and his stance as a post-liberal thinker. He argues that the American founding is deeply rooted in classical philosophy rather than purely Enlightenment ideals. During their conversation, Knowles advocates for a greater role of religion in public life and policy, emphasizing its importance for social cohesion. He also critiques the extremes of libertarianism and communism, suggesting a balanced, pragmatic approach focused on community and tradition.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Founding Was More Classical Than Purely Liberal
- Michael Knowles argues the American Revolution was more conservative and classical than purely Enlightenment liberal.
- He cites Burke, the Federalist Papers, and antiquity as stronger influences than radical Enlightenment ideals.
Constitution As A Mixed Classical Regime
- Knowles identifies the Constitution as a mixed regime echoing Aristotle, Polybius, and Aquinas.
- He sees executive, aristocratic, and democratic elements intentionally balanced to avoid regime cycles.
Rhetoric Versus Practice In The Revolution
- Knowles says the Revolution's rhetoric used Enlightenment language but its practice relied on discipline, institutions, and elite stewardship.
- He emphasizes ordered, top-down conduct and historical continuity prevented French-style terror.