The PROBLEM With Labour’s Illegal Immigration Plans

Nov 18, 2025

Rob Bates, founder of the Centre for Migration Control, dissects Labour's proposed immigration reforms, shedding light on hidden issues like visa overstayers and the significant financial burden of asylum hotels. He critiques the 'jewellery clause' as a weak deterrent and highlights the failures of current border enforcement, with small boat crossings representing only a fraction of a deeper crisis. Bates also discusses the complexities of asylum laws and the misuse of the Modern Slavery Act, advising on more effective migration management strategies.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Data Gaps Skew Immigration Debate

The Centre for Migration Control finds government data gaps drive contested immigration narratives.
Rob Bates says FOIs and detailed analysis reveal realities policymakers often ignore.

ANECDOTE

Sky Fact-Check Saga Over Afghan Crime Rates

Rob Bates recounts the Sky News dispute over Afghan sexual offence rates and mismatched denominators.
He argues the Ministry of Justice provided nationality data while critics used country-of-birth denominators.

INSIGHT

20-Year Route Isn’t Absolute Deterrent

Mahmood's 20-year settlement route targets illegal entrants but includes off-ramps to work, study, and sponsorship.
Bates says this still grants many immediate rights, so deterrent effects are limited.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Get a better way to stay informed at https://ground.news/winston and see through biased media. Subscribe through my link for 40% off unlimited access.

Britain is at a breaking point, and on this episode of The Winston Marshall Show, I sit down with Rob Bates, founder of the Centre for Migration Control, for a forensic breakdown of Shabana Mahmood’s new asylum and immigration reforms.

We dig into what these proposals really mean: from 20-year settlement routes, the so-called “jewellery clause,” and Labour’s attempt to reframe illegal Channel crossings as an acceptable path to refugee status to the ballooning cost of asylum hotels, the collapse of border enforcement, and how Britain ended up spending billions housing people the state has lost track of.

Rob exposes the shocking scale of visa overstayers, the true size of the illegal migrant population, and why the small boats crisis is only the visible tip of a much larger system failure. We explore the data wars, crime figures, FOI revelations, nationality vs. country-of-birth disputes, and the politicised fight over who gets to define the truth.

We also get into the deeper structural rot: the ECHR bottleneck, the Modern Slavery Act being gamed, human rights loopholes exploited by foreign offenders, and how gangs, trafficking networks, and the black-market economy have embedded themselves into Britain’s immigration system.

All this, small boat crossings, overstayers, asylum hotels, the £16 billion bill, ECHR constraints, crime data controversies, and the political revolt inside Labour in a conversation cutting through the spin to what’s really happening at Britain’s borders.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

To see more exclusive content and interviews consider subscribing to my substack here: https://www.winstonmarshall.co.uk/

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA:

Substack: https://www.winstonmarshall.co.uk/

X: https://twitter.com/mrwinmarshall

Insta: https://www.instagram.com/winstonmarshall

Linktree: https://linktr.ee/winstonmarshall

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.