Join Ash Sarkar, a prominent voice on masculinity, historian Tim Stanley, and NHS leader Matthew Taylor as they tackle the pressing issues surrounding modern manhood. They explore the impact of social media on young men's identities, the rise of misogyny, and the clash between traditional and evolving gender roles. Clare Ford shares insights from her work with teens, while John Amaechi discusses emotional intelligence. With contribution from contrarian Brendan O'Neill and author James Bloodworth, this discussion navigates the complex landscape of masculinity today.
The podcast highlights a crisis of masculinity among boys as they struggle with identity amidst changing gender roles and societal expectations.
It emphasizes the detrimental impact of online influences, such as harmful role models, which exacerbate emotional suppression and lead to negative mindsets in young men.
The discussion advocates for a balanced approach to masculinity that encourages emotional expression and vulnerability while respecting traditional masculine traits like strength and stoicism.
Deep dives
Crisis in Masculinity
The podcast examines a report indicating a significant underachievement crisis among boys compared to their female counterparts, highlighting how traditional male virtues are being dismantled. It illustrates a generation influenced more by negative online role models than by positive familial figures, with boys often having smartphones as their primary source of guidance over absent fathers. The narrative is supported by a Netflix series that portrays a disturbing societal view on masculinity, showing how boys, portrayed in a story about violence, are grappling with emerging male identities in an unfavorable context. This situation leads to widespread emotional suppression amongst young men, resulting in increased susceptibility to harmful ideologies found online.
Impact of Toxic Influences
Discussion touches on the emotional reticence of boys, as they often feel compelled to seek validation from peers or the internet rather than healthy familial relationships, thus exacerbating their isolation. One guest emphasizes the role of media in shaping these dynamics, suggesting that while media could depict healthy expressions of masculinity, it often embraces toxic narratives instead. The conversation broadens to discuss how the current portrayal of male emotions tends to reflect societal difficulties, showing an alarming trend of suppressed emotional literacy leading to destructive behavior. Furthermore, this lack of emotional outlets, combined with hyper-exposure to violent gaming and internet subcultures, cultivates negative mindsets that mislead young males regarding their roles in society.
Modern Masculinity vs. Traditional Values
A central theme of the podcast revolves around the differing perspectives of what constitutes masculinity in modern times compared to conventional views. Some panelists advocate for a return to traditional masculine traits such as strength and stoicism, suggesting that these traits have been unfairly demonized. Others argue that emotional expression and vulnerability should be championed without losing touch with the heritage of masculinity. The discussion ultimately questions whether allowing boys to embrace their boyish traits while also progressing emotionally could bridge the gap between outdated masculinity and the evolving societal expectations.
The Role of Parenting and Socialization
The podcast emphasizes the significance of parenting styles and societal expectations in shaping young boys' identities, exploring how early gender biases affect emotional development. Experts argue that while traditional masculinity has virtues, modern parenting must adapt to include teaching emotional intelligence and compassion without compromising identity. This reframing requires parents to acknowledge their biases to cultivate a healthy environment where boys feel safe to express themselves. It also highlights the importance of role models and positive reinforcement through community engagements that allow young males to develop into balanced adults.
Navigating Online Influences
In the conversation, the detrimental role of online platforms in influencing young men is underscored, with specific mention of figures like Andrew Tate amplifying harmful views on women and masculinity. The podcast notes that social media can create a false narrative for boys that equates dominance and misogyny with success, perpetuating cycles of insecurity. It is suggested that many young males are still developing the capability to discern these negative influences, often leading them towards inappropriate communities instead of healthy interactions. The need for a strong, supportive, social framework is reiterated, advocating for real-life connections to help navigate the challenges posed by the digital landscape.
The Netflix drama ‘Adolescence’ has prompted a national conversation about a ‘crisis of masculinity’. In a society where gender roles are changing, progressive attitudes are in tension with traditional ideas about male behaviour.
Studies suggest Gen Z men and women are more divided than those of any other generation on questions about feminism, gender roles and women’s rights. Meanwhile, teachers highlight the alarming prevalence of misogyny in schools, influencers can be influential than parents, and social media algorithms amplify misogynistic content to teens. This is happening at the same time as rising rates of depression, anxiety, and a higher likelihood of suicide among young men.
Traditional ideas about ‘manliness’ - strength, dominance, independence, and emotional stoicism - are seen in many contexts as inappropriate and harmful – both to men and women. While the feminist movement and women’s advances in education and the workplace, for example, are a mark of social progress, some believe they have also challenged men’s sense of purpose in a way that has perhaps been overlooked. Others think this analysis is dangerous because it doesn’t apply to all men, it sets up men's mental health and wellbeing in opposition to the opportunities of women, and denies some men the agency to make the right choices. At the same time, it can be uncomfortable to discuss how men and women are different – physically and psychologically – and how they might have different and complementary roles.
Do we need to re-define or reclaim masculinity? What’s wrong with men?
Chair: Michael Buerk
Producer: Dan Tierney
Assistant Producer: Peter Everett
Editor: Tim Pemberton
Panel:
Ash Sarkar
Tim Stanley
Matthew Taylor
Anne McElvoy
Witnesses:
Clare Ford
Brendan O'Neill
James Bloodworth
John Amaechi
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode