Consider This from NPR Does Trump's plan to get homeless people off the streets violate civil liberties?
16 snips
Sep 23, 2025 Brian Mann, a seasoned radio reporter with in-depth knowledge of homelessness and civil commitment, discusses Trump's controversial plan to address homelessness. He explains the implications of forcing individuals into long-term treatment for addiction and mental health issues. Critics raise alarms about civil liberties and financial costs, while some Democratic leaders show support for these civil commitment measures. The conversation dives into the historical context of mental health policy and the potential future of these contentious proposals.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Federal Push For Expanded Civil Commitment
- Trump's executive order promotes expanding civil commitment to move homeless people into long-term institutional settings.
- The policy aims to mandate care for homelessness tied to mental illness and addiction, raising rights and scope questions.
Portrait Of A Vulnerable Individual
- Brian Mann describes meeting David, a 35-year-old living on Portland's streets who fears the government and reports being abducted.
- David says he doesn't use drugs or have mental illness but appears disoriented and receives no help.
Forced Treatment Can Undermine Recovery
- Morgan Godwin, a former addict, says forced treatment slowed her recovery and increased fear of providers.
- Experts warn civil commitment can harm trust and backfire unless used sparingly for immediate danger.