“Reliable Sources: The Story of David Gerard” by TracingWoodgrains
Jul 11, 2024
auto_awesome
David Gerard, a long-standing critic of rationalist and EA communities, discusses his standards for reliable sources, his involvement with LessWrong and Effective Altruism, conflicts within online communities, and his contentious actions on Wikipedia, leading to bans from editing certain articles.
David Gerard rigorously upholds source reliability on Wikipedia, shaping article content with discretion.
Gerard's editing tactics spark debates and controversies within the Wikipedia community, advocating for meticulous evaluation of source credibility.
Gerard strategically manipulates article content on Wikipedia to align with his viewpoints, engaging in conflict of interest editing.
Deep dives
David Gerrard: The Wikipedia Administrator
David Gerrard, a long-time Wikipedia administrator, is deeply dedicated to upholding the integrity of sources on the platform. With relentless commitment, he scrutinizes and edits content leveraging his intricate understanding of Wikipedia's policies. Gerrard meticulously distinguishes between reliable and unreliable sources, ensuring only accurate and verifiable information is presented to readers.
Gerard's Standards for Reliable Sources
Gerard's unwavering stance on maintaining the credibility of sources has led to conflicts within the Wikipedia community. Despite objections, he staunchly advocates for removing content from sources deemed unreliable. His approach has sparked debates, with some questioning the indiscriminate removals and advocating for a more nuanced evaluation of source reliability.
A Closer Look at Gerard's Editorial Approach
Gerard's editorial tactics involve incrementally shaping articles to align with his viewpoints. He strategically removes neutral information not in line with his narrative and aggressively defends his edits against dissenting voices. By leveraging Wikipedia policies and engaging in persistent editing, he asserts his influence on article content.
Gerard's Focus on Less Wrong and Neoreactionaries
Gerard's intense focus on Less Wrong, coupled with attempts to draw associations between rationalists and neoreactionaries, underscores his dedication to crafting specific narratives. Through meticulous editing and persistent engagement, he aims to influence how these communities are perceived, emphasizing their interconnectedness and distinct characteristics.
David Gerard's Controversial Wikipedia Editing History
David Gerard's editing style on Wikipedia involved manipulating articles related to various individuals and movements he disagreed with, including the effective altruism community and the rationalist Scott Alexander. Gerard displayed a pattern of selectively using sources and engaging in conflict of interest editing, particularly evident in his extensive efforts to shape articles about Scott Alexander, revealing a personal grudge and persistent attempts to influence narratives.
Gerard's Extensive Wikipedia Influence and Controversies
Over a span of many years, David Gerard wielded significant influence on Wikipedia, showcasing a pattern of contentious editing practices and deeply rooted biases. His approach to editing articles, particularly those related to individuals and movements he opposed, reflected a consistent effort to assert his viewpoints, manipulate sources, and circumvent Wikipedia's guidelines, ultimately leading to scrutiny and a ban from editing specific topics.
This is a linkpost for https://www.tracingwoodgrains.com/p/reliable-sources-how-wikipedia-admin, posted in full here given its relevance to this community. Gerard has been one of the longest-standing malicious critics of the rationalist and EA communities and has done remarkable amounts of work to shape their public images behind the scenes.
Note: I am closer to this story than to many of my others. As always, I write aiming to provide a thorough and honest picture, but this should be read as the view of a close onlooker who has known about much within this story for years and has strong opinions about the matter, not a disinterested observer coming across something foreign and new. If you’re curious about the backstory, I encourage you to read my companion article after this one.
Introduction: Reliable Sources
Wikipedia administrator David Gerard cares a great deal about Reliable Sources. For the past half-decade, he has torn [...]
---
Outline:
(00:55) Introduction: Reliable Sources
(06:01) Gerard's Standards for Reliable Sources
(13:53) Who Is David Gerard?
(16:53) The Early Romantic Years
(28:00) Gerard's fling with LessWrong in the twilight of the old internet
(37:51) The bitter end
(45:26) The Vindictive Ex
(50:01) LessWrong
(01:04:17) Effective Altruism
(01:07:55) Scott Alexander
(01:16:22) Conclusion
(01:21:58) Companion article: A Young Mormon Discovers Online Rationality
The original text contained 24 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.
The original text contained 12 images which were described by AI.