Shedunnit The Crimes of Dorothy Erskine Muir
Apr 30, 2025
Dive into the fascinating life of Dorothy Erskine Muir, a pioneering detective novelist who fused real unsolved crimes with fiction. Discover her struggle for independence and resilience as she navigates a challenging upbringing and the aftermath of World War I. The exploration of early 20th-century crime fiction reveals how societal tensions influenced her writing. With intriguing insights on how crime narratives provide resolution, this journey showcases Muir's unique contributions to the genre and the psychological depth within her mysteries.
33:40
Crime Fiction's Satisfying Closure
- Crime fiction offers a satisfying, complete resolution that true crime often cannot provide.
- Real-life crimes are often unsolvable or obscured, which challenges those who seek definitive answers.
Muir's Detective Novels' Origin
- Dorothy Erskine Muir published only three detective novels, largely inspired by unsolved murder cases.
- Her background and personal history deeply influenced her approach to crime fiction.
Dorothy's Early Life and Family
- Dorothy grew up in a large family with Victorian values, moving from poverty to a bishop's palace.
- Despite loneliness, she found companionship with her younger brother and household staff.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 2min
Exploring Crime Through Fiction: The Unconventional Journey of a Detective Novelist
02:20 • 3min
Dorothy's Journey: From Isolation to Independence
04:55 • 9min
Emergence of a Crime Fiction Pioneer
13:33 • 2min
Murder Mysteries: Fact and Fiction
15:56 • 14min
Exploring the Dark Depths of Detective Fiction
29:37 • 4min
In Memory of Charles
None
Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dorothy Erskine Muir's 'In Memory of Charles' marks a departure from her previous novels, though still inspired by a real-life case.
The novel shifts focus from the procedural aspects of investigation to character psychology and social dynamics.
The murder of Charles, an unpleasant patriarch, sets off a chain of events that expose the tensions within his family and the community.
The book explores themes of class conflict and the dark side of human nature.
While the source material remains unidentified, the novel stands as a compelling exploration of human relationships and the consequences of unchecked power.
In Muffled Night
None
Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dorothy Erskine Muir's 'In Muffled Night' masterfully blends fact and fiction, drawing inspiration from the unsolved Sandiford murder case of 1862.
The novel transplants the setting and characters, yet retains the core elements of the real-life crime.
Muir's narrative explores themes of class, justice, and the limitations of true crime narratives.
The fictional resolution provides a satisfying conclusion absent from the original case, prompting reflection on the nature of truth and justice.
The book's clever plotting and atmospheric descriptions make it a compelling read.
Trial of Oscar Slater
The Making of the Modern Law: Trials, 1600-1926
William Roughead
William Roughead's 'The Trial of Oscar Slater' is a detailed account of the controversial trial that wrongly convicted Oscar Slater for murder.
The book meticulously examines the evidence presented, highlighting the numerous flaws and inconsistencies in the prosecution's case.
Roughead's analysis played a crucial role in bringing attention to the miscarriage of justice.
The book details the circumstantial evidence, questionable witness testimonies, and prejudiced atmosphere of the trial.
'The Trial of Oscar Slater' stands as a powerful example of how flawed legal processes can lead to wrongful convictions.
A Pin to See the Peepshow
British Library Women Writers
Gladys Mitchell
Further information is needed to provide a detailed description of F. Tennyson Jesse's 'A Pin to See the Peepshow'.
However, based on the podcast transcript, it is known that the novel is inspired by the Edith Thompson case, a real-life crime.
This suggests that the novel may explore themes of justice, betrayal, and the complexities of human relationships.
More details about the plot and characters are required for a comprehensive summary.
The novel's connection to the Edith Thompson case makes it a potentially significant work within Jesse's body of work.
When Last I Died
Gladys Mitchell
Gladys Mitchell's 'When Last I Died' is a classic Golden Age detective novel featuring the eccentric and insightful Mrs. Bradley.
The novel unfolds with a murder mystery that Mrs. Bradley must solve, showcasing her unique approach to detection.
The plot is cleverly constructed, with red herrings and unexpected twists.
'When Last I Died' is a fine example of the Golden Age detective novel, blending mystery, humor, and social commentary.
Jumping Jenny
Jumping Jenny
Anthony Berkeley
Anthony Berkeley's 'Jumping Jenny' is a classic Golden Age detective novel featuring Roger Sheringham.
The novel unfolds at a lively costume party where a murder occurs, adding an element of intrigue and disguise to the mystery.
Sheringham's sharp wit and deductive reasoning are key to solving the crime.
The plot is cleverly constructed, with unexpected twists and turns that keep the reader engaged.
'Jumping Jenny' is a fine example of the Golden Age detective novel, blending mystery, humor, and social commentary.
Three is a Lucky Number
Three is a Lucky Number
null
Margery Allingham
Margery Allingham's 'Three is a Lucky Number' is a short story that offers a fictional counterpoint to the real-life Brides in the Bath murders.
The story likely reimagines the events, providing a different outcome and exploring themes of justice and retribution.
Allingham's signature style, characterized by atmospheric descriptions and insightful character portrayals, is likely present.
The story serves as a fascinating example of how fiction can engage with and reinterpret true crime narratives.
Further details are needed for a complete summary.
The case of Oscar Slater
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's 'The Case of Oscar Slater' is a compelling account of his involvement in securing the release of Oscar Slater, wrongly convicted of murder.
The book details Conan Doyle's investigation into the case, highlighting the flaws in the original trial and the circumstantial nature of the evidence against Slater.
Conan Doyle's reputation and influence played a significant role in bringing attention to the miscarriage of justice.
The book showcases Conan Doyle's commitment to justice and his use of his skills in deduction and investigation to fight for the innocent.
'The Case of Oscar Slater' is a testament to the power of advocacy and the importance of fighting for justice.
A history of Milan under the Visconti
A history of Milan under the Visconti
Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dorothy Erskine Muir's 'A History of Milan Under the Visconti' is a scholarly work that delves into the political, social, and cultural history of Milan during the Visconti period.
The book likely provides a detailed account of the Visconti family's rule, their impact on the city, and the broader historical context.
Muir's academic background and research skills are evident in the book's thoroughness and depth of analysis.
The work likely offers valuable insights into the political landscape and social structures of medieval Milan.
'A History of Milan Under the Visconti' stands as a testament to Muir's academic prowess and her dedication to historical research.
Five to Five
None
Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dorothy Erskine Muir's 'Five to Five' continues her exploration of true crime through fiction, this time focusing on the 1908 Slater case.
The novel shifts the setting to London but maintains the core details of the original crime.
Muir's narrative delves into themes of justice, prejudice, and the fallibility of the legal system.
The fictional resolution provides a satisfying conclusion, contrasting with the real-life unsolved case.
The book's exploration of character and motive adds depth to the mystery.
Trent's last case
Trent's last case
E. C. Bentley
E. C.
Bentley's 'Trent's Last Case' is a landmark work in the Golden Age of Detective Fiction.
The novel introduces Philip Trent, a journalist-detective with a sharp wit and keen observational skills.
Trent investigates a murder case involving a wealthy family and a web of secrets.
The plot is intricate and suspenseful, with unexpected twists and turns.
'Trent's Last Case' is praised for its clever plotting, memorable characters, and insightful social commentary.
The novel's influence on subsequent detective fiction is undeniable.
Lift the curtain
Lift the curtain
Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dorothy Erskine Muir's 'Lift the Curtain' is a personal memoir offering a glimpse into her unique upbringing within a large family.
The book details her childhood experiences, highlighting the contrasts between her early life in a vicarage and later years in a bishop's palace.
Muir's reflections on her family dynamics and educational experiences provide valuable context for understanding her writing.
The memoir also touches upon the significant events that shaped her life, including the loss of her brother and husband.
'Lift the Curtain' offers a fascinating insight into the life and influences of a remarkable writer.
Heaven knows who
Heaven knows who
Christianna Brand
Christianna Brand's 'Heaven Knows Who' is a non-fiction work focusing on the Sandiford case, a notorious unsolved murder from the 19th century.
The book likely examines the evidence, the suspects, and the various theories surrounding the crime.
Brand's work probably explores the lasting impact of the case on public perception and the challenges of solving cold cases.
The title itself reflects the enduring uncertainty surrounding the identity of the killer.
The book serves as a testament to the enduring fascination with unsolved mysteries.
Lord Edgware Dies
Agatha Christie
Agatha Christie's 'Lord Edgware Dies' is a thrilling mystery featuring Hercule Poirot.
The novel centers around the murder of a prominent theatrical figure, Lord Edgware.
Poirot's sharp intellect and meticulous observation skills are put to the test as he unravels a complex web of secrets and lies.
The plot is filled with suspenseful twists and turns, keeping the reader guessing until the very end.
'Lord Edgware Dies' is a classic example of Christie's masterful storytelling, showcasing her ability to create intricate plots and memorable characters.
Ask a Policeman
Ask a Policeman
Dorothy L. Sayers
Further information is needed to provide a detailed description of 'Ask a Policeman'.
However, based on the podcast transcript, it is known that the book is a collaborative work by The Detection Club, a group of Golden Age mystery writers.
This suggests that the book is a collection of short stories, each likely featuring a different author's unique style and approach to mystery.
More details about the individual stories and their themes are required for a comprehensive summary.
The book's collaborative nature makes it a significant example of the collaborative spirit within the Golden Age of Detective Fiction.
Busman's honeymoon
Busman's honeymoon
Dorothy L. Sayers
Dorothy L. Sayers's 'Busman's Honeymoon' is a delightful continuation of the Lord Peter Wimsey and Harriet Vane series.
The novel follows the newly married couple as they embark on their honeymoon, which is unexpectedly interrupted by a murder investigation.
Sayers's sharp wit and keen observation of human nature are on full display.
The plot is cleverly constructed, with red herrings and unexpected twists.
'Busman's Honeymoon' is a charming and engaging mystery, offering both intellectual stimulation and lighthearted entertainment.
And Then There Were None
Agatha Christie
In this classic murder mystery, ten strangers are lured to Indian Island, off the coast of Devon, by an unknown host.
Each guest has a dark secret and is accused of a past crime by a recorded voice.
As the guests are murdered one by one, following the pattern of the nursery rhyme 'Ten Little Indians,' the remaining survivors must uncover the killer's identity before they become the next victims.
The novel is known for its intricate plot, surprising twists, and its exploration of themes such as justice, guilt, and class distinctions.
Murder Must Advertise
Murder Must Advertise
Jane McDowell
Dorothy L. Sayers
Believing Is Seeing
Believing Is Seeing
Carol Joy
Fact meets fiction in the work of this unjustly overlooked writer.
Moonstone Press are very kindly running a special offer for the 30 days after this episode airs: if you buy the paperback set of Erskine Muir's three novels, you get three for the price of two and the podcast gets a little commission for referring you. Take advantage of the special offer at moonstonepress.co.uk.
Click here to take part in the Shedunnit Audience Survey.
Books mentioned in this episode:— In Muffled Night by Dorothy Erskine Muir— Five to Five by Dorothy Erskine Muir— In Memory of Charles by Dorothy Erskine Muir— Lift the Curtain by Dorothy Erskine Muir— A History of Milan Under the Visconti by Dorothy Erskine Muir— Ask a Policeman by The Detection Club— Murder Must Advertise by Dorothy L Sayers— Lord Edgware Dies by Agatha Christie— Jumping Jenny by Anthony Berkeley— Seeing is Believing by John Dickson Carr— Heaven Knows Who by Christianna Brand— Trent's Last Case by E.C. Bentley— Busman's Honeymoon by Dorothy L Sayers— When Last I Died by Gladys Mitchell— A Pin to See the Peepshow by F. Tennyson Jesse— "Three is a Lucky Number" by Margery Allinhgam— The Trial of Oscar Slater by William Roughead— The Case of Oscar Slater by Arthur Conan Doyle— And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
Support the podcast by joining the Shedunnit Book Club and get extra Shedunnit episodes every month plus access to the monthly reading discussions and community: shedunnitbookclub.com/join.
NB: Links to Blackwell's are affiliate links, meaning that the podcast receives a small commission when you purchase a book there (the price remains the same for you). Blackwell's is a UK bookselling chain that ships internationally at no extra charge.
To be the first to know about future developments with the podcast, sign up for the newsletter at shedunnitshow.com/newsletter.
You can find the podcast in all major podcast apps. Make sure you’re subscribed so you don’t miss the next episode. Click here to do that now in your app of choice.
Music by Audioblocks and Blue Dot Sessions. See shedunnitshow.com/musiccredits for more details.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices