Aurelian Craiutu, a political science professor at Indiana University and expert on moderation, dives into the complexities of liberalism and its internal challenges. He argues that threats to liberal democracy are emerging from within Western societies, rather than external regimes. Craiutu highlights the importance of political moderation as a counterbalance to extremism, sharing insights from his experience growing up in Romania under communism. He stresses the need for engaging with diverse perspectives and fostering dialogue to defend liberal values in today's polarized climate.
01:16:50
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Liberalism's Complexity and Dimensions
Liberalism is not a singular doctrine but a diverse family of doctrines with political, economic, moral, legal, and religious dimensions.
Understanding these multiple liberalisms helps counter the notion that liberal democracy is in straightforward decline.
insights INSIGHT
Liberalism Challenged From Within
The main challengers to liberalism arise from within Western democracies, not from illiberal regimes abroad.
These critiques arise from real societal issues such as identity and a longing for roots, which liberalism has often neglected.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Growing Up Under Communism
Aurelian Craiutu's upbringing under Romania's communist regime taught him the fragility of liberal freedoms.
He learned the importance of civil society and freedoms like speech and association through personal experience.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
What is moderation? The term is used both positively and pejoratively in today’s political discourse but rarely is it defined. Aurelian Craiutu is a professor of political science at Indiana University in Bloomington who has, perhaps more than anyone else, tried to define moderation and its manifestations in politics and philosophy over the past several centuries. He is the author of major works on moderation, including A Virtue for Courageous Minds: Moderation in French Political Thought, 1748-1830, and Faces of Moderation: The Art of Balance in an Age of Extremes.
In this podcast discussion, Aurelian discusses his historical research into moderation and his theoretical analyses of moderation and its relation to different varieties of liberalism. He considers the political, economic, moral, legal, and religious aspects of liberalism and why liberalism (as well as moderation) is under threat from both left and right. And, he reminds us, the leading challengers to both liberalism and moderation today do not come from hostile regimes like Russia or China but from within Western democracies. Unlike some of liberalism’s defenders, he concedes that conservative critics of liberalism respond to real problems in contemporary societies.
Aurelian was born in communist Romania during the regime of Nicolae Ceaușescu, and he discusses how the absence of key liberal and moderate values in that society made him appreciate both the fragility of liberal civilization and the importance of moderation as an antidote to zealotry and fanaticism. He sketches some of the political and ethical components of moderation, including an aversion to fanaticism and epistemological arrogance. He also discusses some thinkers who embodied aspects of moderation, including French sociologist Raymond Aron and Polish activist Adam Michnik. He calls for moderates to resist the temptation to turn opponents into enemies, for people on both the left and the right to “read across the aisle,” and for Republicans and Democrats to foster “a climate that promotes dialogue, humility, moderation, compromise, [and] anything that opposes fanaticism.”
The Vital Center 
