Malcolm Woolf, CEO of the National Hydropower Association, teams up with Connor Nelson, an insightful author focusing on hydropower's impact in the clean energy sector. They discuss the crucial yet often overshadowed role of hydropower in stabilizing the energy grid amidst the rise of renewables. Delving into the lengthy relicensing challenges and inadequate market compensation, they emphasize the urgent need for reforms. The conversation also highlights opportunities for enhancing hydropower capacity, ensuring it remains a foundational part of America's clean energy future.
Hydropower plays a crucial, yet often overlooked role in providing reliable energy storage that supports the integration of solar and wind power into the grid.
The lengthy and complex relicensing process for hydropower facilities poses significant challenges, leading to concerns about the future viability of this essential energy source.
Current market compensation structures inadequately recognize the unique grid services provided by hydropower, highlighting the need for urgent reassessment to encourage continued investment.
Deep dives
The Importance of Hydropower in the Energy Mix
Hydropower plays a significant role in the U.S. energy landscape, providing about 6.2% of total electricity generation. It consists of 80 gigawatts of traditional hydropower and 22 gigawatts of pumped storage, which is crucial for long-duration energy storage. While it doesn't dominate the energy mix like solar or wind, it is vital for grid reliability, helping to ensure that users can consistently access electricity despite fluctuations in renewable energy output. The need for clean firm generation sources, which hydropower exemplifies, is growing as the country transitions toward a cleaner energy future.
Unique Attributes of Hydropower
Hydropower's flexibility allows it to serve as both a baseload and a dispatchable energy source, enabling rapid adjustments to power output in response to grid demands. It provides essential grid services, such as inertia and frequency regulation, which help maintain a stable electricity supply even during extreme weather or emergencies. This dual capability sets hydropower apart from other renewable sources, addressing the challenges of integrating variable renewable energy like wind and solar into the grid. Its ability to supply Black Start services underscores its critical role in recovering from grid outages.
Challenges of Licensing and Relicensing
Many existing hydropower facilities face significant obstacles related to the relicensing process, which can take up to a decade or longer, raising concerns about the viability of these critical energy resources. Although most hydropower plants are moving through the licensing process, there is a rising trend of facilities voluntarily surrendering their licenses, mainly due to the burdensome costs and uncertainties associated with relicensing. The disconnect arises because while the structures may remain functional for much longer, the regulatory framework mandates a reevaluation every 50 years, creating an environment where some owners may opt to discontinue operations instead. This reluctance could lead to a concerning decline in hydropower capacity, ultimately affecting grid reliability.
Market Compensation and Value Recognition Issues
Hydropower's unique contributions to grid services are not adequately reflected in market compensation structures, resulting in a failure to recognize its true value in a rapidly changing energy landscape. Critical ancillary services provided by hydropower, such as frequency support and voltage control, often lack appropriate financial compensation, limiting the incentives for continued investment in these facilities. Moreover, the pressures of operating costs have led some facilities to incur losses when trying to fulfill these essential services. An urgent reevaluation of compensation mechanisms in regional energy markets is necessary to ensure that hydropower remains a viable and recognized asset within the clean energy transition.
Future Potential of Hydropower Infrastructure
Despite the historical stagnation in dam construction, there is significant untapped potential for expanding hydropower generation by adding capacity to existing non-powered dams. Estimates suggest that there could be an addition of approximately 13 gigawatts of generation through upgrades to these non-powered structures. Furthermore, innovations in pumped storage technology present opportunities for new developments, particularly in closed-loop systems which do not require river access. Collaborative efforts towards streamlining the licensing process for such projects could unlock a new wave of hydropower capacity, essential for balancing the needs of a variable energy grid.
In this episode, I speak with Malcolm Woolf and Connor Nelson about hydropower's underappreciated role in America's clean energy landscape. While providing most of our energy storage and thus supporting solar and wind deployments, hydropower faces significant challenges, with a decade-long relicensing processes and inadequate market compensation. We discuss why preserving and expanding this reliable, clean firm energy source is crucial as we transition to renewables.
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode