Kevin J. Mitchell, "Free Agents: How Evolution Gave Us Free Will" (Princeton UP, 2023)
Oct 1, 2023
auto_awesome
Leading neuroscientist Kevin J. Mitchell discusses how evolution gave us free will and challenges the idea that agency is an illusion. He explores the emergence of nervous systems, the power of meaning in neural activity, and the role of genetics in shaping our individual nature. Mitchell's argument has important implications for decision making, individual and collective agency, and the future of artificial intelligence.
Despite claims that free will is an illusion, leading neuroscientist Kevin Mitchell argues that humans are agents with purpose, not mere machines responding to physical forces.
The development of control systems, natural selection, and causal knowledge accumulation enable organisms, including humans, to exert causal power in decision-making and action.
Deep dives
The Nature vs. Nurture Question and Free Will
The podcast explores the author's interest in how the brain gets wired and its connection to behavioral traits, personality, intelligence, and risk of psychiatric or neurological conditions. This leads to the question of whether individuals really have free will if their decision-making is influenced by genetics and predetermined by brain wiring.
Challenges to the Concept of Free Will
The podcast discusses the current trend among some neuroscientists to declare free will as an illusion, arguing that all decisions are simply the result of neural circuits firing. The author challenges this view, suggesting that the meaning of neural patterns is crucial and holds the causal power in decision-making. The argument emphasizes that decisions are not purely mechanistic, but driven by the meaning attributed to neural patterns and cognitive elements.
The Emergence of Control Systems and Meaning in Organisms
The podcast delves into the development of control systems in living organisms, starting from single-celled organisms to more complex beings like humans. It highlights the importance of integrating signals from the environment, detecting meaning, and making choices that align with survival and persistence. The author emphasizes that the process of natural selection and the accumulation of causal knowledge enable organisms to exert causal power in the world.
Implications for Identity and Artificial Intelligence
The podcast explores the implications of the understanding of free will for human identity and ethics. It suggests that our existing notions of free will and responsibility align well with the biological perspective discussed. However, it highlights the need to consider the ethics of developing artificial general intelligence that exhibits similar agency and cognition. The discussion also touches on the ethical questions surrounding the embodiment of artificial intelligence and the potential consequences of such developments.
Scientists are learning more and more about how brain activity controls behavior and how neural circuits weigh alternatives and initiate actions. As we probe ever deeper into the mechanics of decision making, many conclude that agency--or free will--is an illusion. In Free Agents: How Evolution Gave Us Free Will (Princeton UP, 2023), leading neuroscientist Kevin Mitchell presents a wealth of evidence to the contrary, arguing that we are not mere machines responding to physical forces but agents acting with purpose.
Traversing billions of years of evolution, Mitchell tells the remarkable story of how living beings capable of choice arose from lifeless matter. He explains how the emergence of nervous systems provided a means to learn about the world, granting sentient animals the capacity to model, predict, and simulate. Mitchell reveals how these faculties reached their peak in humans with our abilities to imagine and to be introspective, to reason in the moment, and to shape our possible futures through the exercise of our individual agency. Mitchell's argument has important implications--for how we understand decision making, for how our individual agency can be enhanced or infringed, for how we think about collective agency in the face of global crises, and for how we consider the limitations and future of artificial intelligence.
An astonishing journey of discovery, Free Agents offers a new framework for understanding how, across a billion years of Earth history, life evolved the power to choose, and why it matters.