Why Men Struggle to Keep Friends and How to Reignite Brotherhood ft. Ethan Hagner

21 snips

Sep 3, 2025

Ethan Hagner, a 19-year-old, explores the complexities of male friendships, particularly how they often fade after high school. He shares his experience with lost connections as friends go separate ways, while discussing the importance of intentionality and vulnerability in maintaining brotherhood. The conversation shifts to how friendships evolve through life stages, the challenges of making new friends as responsibilities grow, and the significance of consistent communication in rekindling valuable relationships. It's a candid reflection on the necessity of male camaraderie.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Achievement Doesn’t Replace Brotherhood

Male friendships often fade because convenience and proximity drive them during school years.
Achievement later in life cannot replace the emotional connection that brotherhood provides.

INSIGHT

Proximity Is The Hidden Glue

Friendships in school depend on forced proximity like classes and sports.
Once that shared context disappears, common ground and connection often erode.

ANECDOTE

The 3 A.M. Friend Who Returned

Larry describes a 3 a.m. friend he reconnected with after military deployment and years apart.
They picked up like no time had passed, illustrating durable core friendships.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

In this episode of the Dad Edge Podcast, Ethan and I dive into a topic most men don’t talk about nearly enough—male friendships. From high school bonds that fade after graduation to the loneliness many men feel in their 30s and 40s, we unpack why brotherhood is so hard to maintain and why it matters more than ever.

We share personal stories, both from Ethan’s perspective at 19 and my experience at 50, about what it looks like to build lasting friendships at different stages of life. From the silent killers of connection—busyness, unspoken expectations, and lack of intentionality—to the keys that keep brotherhood alive, this episode is a raw and honest roadmap for men who don’t want to go through life alone.

TIMELINE SUMMARY

[0:00] - Welcome to the Dad Edge movement and today’s theme: friendships and brotherhood

[1:02] - Why male friendships dwindle after high school

[2:45] - How friendships shift in your 20s, 30s, 40s, and 50s

[4:58] - Why achievement never replaces connection

[6:13] - Ethan’s perspective at 19: losing friends as everyone goes their separate ways

[8:46] - Larry’s college stories: parties, hangovers, and life lessons learned the hard way

[12:23] - The shift from convenience-based friendships to intentional ones

[15:01] - Why men struggle to make new friendships as they age

[17:30] - The role of shared struggle, vulnerability, and consistency in building brotherhood

[21:10] - Why “let’s hang out sometime” rarely works—and what to do instead

[25:18] - Larry’s example of rekindling friendships with intentional planning

[28:35] - How marriage and fatherhood shift men’s priorities and isolate them

[31:05] - The silent killers of friendship: busyness, lack of vulnerability, inconsistency

[34:16] - Why brotherhood is essential for emotional, spiritual, and relational health

[37:02] - Advice for young men: stay proactive, visit friends, make memories now

[41:33] - How to prevent friendships from fading with intentionality and consistency

[48:11] - Parallels between the silent killers of friendship and the silent killers of marriage

[54:09] - Final reflections: why men need brotherhood and how to fight for it

5 KEY TAKEAWAYS

1. Friendships Require Intentionality

Unlike the easy friendships of high school and college, adult brotherhood must be built with deliberate effort—planning, showing up, and refusing to drift.

2. Achievement Doesn’t Replace Connection

No amount of success, money, or accolades can substitute for the bond of brotherhood. Men need friendships to thrive, not just careers and families.

3. Vulnerability Creates Real Brotherhood

Surface-level conversations keep men distant. True friendship grows when we open up honestly about struggles, challenges, and real life behind the scenes.

4. Consistency Keeps Bonds Alive

Friendships die in silence. Weekly check-ins, shared rituals, or even planned coffee dates create the reps that make brotherhood last.

5. The Same Rules Apply to Marriage

The silent killers of friendship—busyness, lack of vulnerability, loss of intentionality—also destroy marriages. Strong relationships, whether with friends or a spouse, require consistent effort and openness.

LINKS & RESOURCES

DB OVERDRIVE: https://1stphorm.com/products/thyro-drive/?a_aid=dadedge
First Phorm DB Overdrive (supplement featured): https://www.thedadedge.com/1361
25 Questions to Spark Connection With Your Partner: https://www.thedadedge.com/25questions
Dad Edge Podcast Website: https://www.thedadedge.com/podcast
Join The Alliance: https://www.thedadedge.com/alliance
Dad Edge Tools & Resources: https://www.thedadedge.com/tools

If this episode gave you fresh insight into friendship, brotherhood, or marriage, please rate, review, follow, and share the podcast. Let’s build a generation of men who refuse to live life alone.