American Scandal West Memphis Three | Crime and Punishment | 2
11 snips
Dec 2, 2025 The brutal murders of three young boys in West Memphis spark a controversial investigation. A suspect's confession leads to the arrest of two teenagers accused of a satanic ritual. Families voice doubts as contradictions emerge in the confession. Autopsy results raise questions about the planted narrative of sexual assault. Tensions climb during the trial, with defense attorneys challenging critical inconsistencies. Throughout, the prosecutor paints the accused as embodiments of evil, culminating in a shocking guilty verdict that shakes the community.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Confession Outweighs Forensics
- West Memphis police arrested Damien Echols and Jason Baldwin quickly after Jesse Miskelley's confession despite thin physical evidence.
- The confession drove public certainty more than forensic proof in the early investigation.
Triumphant Press Conference
- Police held a press conference claiming the case was closed and displayed high confidence in the arrests.
- Chief Gary Gitchell told reporters he was an "11" on confidence, reflecting public certainty from investigators.
Evidence Was Largely Circumstantial
- Beyond Miskelley's confession, investigators had only weak circumstantial testimony linking the teens to the crime.
- No hair, fingerprint, or blood tied Echols or Baldwin to the murders at that time.
