Michael Janda, a business editor at ABC with a focus on real estate, dives into the puzzling issue of vacant homes in Australia. He discusses alarming statistics highlighting empty properties during a housing crisis. The conversation covers the motivations behind land banking and the frustration from affected communities. Janda debates the potential implementation of a vacancy tax as a solution, weighing the benefits against challenges of enforcement and the broader implications for property rights and government intervention.
Australia is facing a housing crisis with approximately 140,000 vacant homes, raising the need for effective government intervention.
The debate over property rights versus societal needs highlights the complexity of addressing vacant homes and implementing vacancy taxes.
Deep dives
The Extent of Vacant Homes in Australia
A significant number of homes in Australia are currently unoccupied, with estimates suggesting as high as 140,000 vacant homes nationwide. In Melbourne alone, recent research indicated approximately 27,000 homes had zero water usage over a year, coupled with another 70,000 showing low water usage, signaling they are infrequently occupied. Various factors contribute to this vacancy, including properties in disrepair, deceased estates awaiting settlement, financial constraints on development, and the practice of land banking, where owners let properties sit empty to profit from future appreciation in value. These insights reveal the complexity behind the housing crisis, as many dwellings lack inhabitants, yet the reasons for their vacancy vary widely and highlight systemic issues.
Legal and Ethical Considerations of Property Ownership
The concept of property rights comes with a range of legal and ethical debates surrounding the usage of vacant homes. While property owners have the legal right to leave their homes unoccupied, this right is increasingly questioned in light of the housing crisis. Legal experts argue that land ownership has always been subject to regulations, as vacant properties limit access for those in need of housing, drawing a distinction between ownership of movable assets and immovable land. Therefore, the assertion of individual rights must be balanced against the broader societal implications of housing availability, raising the question of whether state intervention should occur.
Potential Solutions to the Housing Crisis
Implementing a vacancy tax presents one approach to alleviate the housing crisis by incentivizing property owners to rent or sell unoccupied homes. This tax already exists in places like San Francisco and parts of Australia and serves to compensate the community for the impact of vacant properties. However, critics argue that there are many valid reasons for properties to remain empty, suggesting that a nuanced approach is needed. While acquiring vacant homes could theoretically address the surplus and contribute to housing solutions, it faces opposition from property owners and requires political will to engage effectively with the issue.
When it’s so hard to find a place to live and buying property is out of reach for many young Australians, you wouldn’t believe how many properties are sitting empty.
What can be done to stop home owners from leaving prime real estate vacant?
Today, the good and bad reasons homes are left vacant and how governments could force owners to get these properties back on the market.
Featured:
Michael Janda, ABC business editor
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode