
NO SUCH THING Why did the rom-com genre fall off?
20 snips
Oct 21, 2026 Journalist and Big Lives co-host Emmanuel Dzotsi joins journalist and author Walt Hickey (You Are What You Watch) to investigate the rom-com’s box-office collapse. They revisit beloved classics, examine how DVDs, streaming, and Hollywood’s missing movie-star machine reshaped the genre, and explore its modern descendants in reality dating shows and television. They even pitch a comeback movie and assemble its dream cast.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Rom-Coms Collapsed After A 2002 Peak
- Rom-coms rose from the 1980s through a $1.6 billion domestic peak in 2002 before collapsing after 2011.
- The genre now earns under $200 million annually, roughly the budget of one major superhero movie.
Emmanuel’s Family Had Every Rom-Com Format
- Emmanuel Dzotsi grew up in a family that watched romantic comedies nearly every weekend.
- Their collection included VHS tapes, DVDs, and even a bootleg filmed inside a theater with people walking past the camera.
DVDs Kept Middle-Budget Movies Alive
- The DVD market once let studios profit from modest theatrical hits, but home-video revenue fell from about $25 billion in 2004 to under $1 billion.
- Without that safety net, studios abandoned middle-budget films for expensive tentpoles or cheap lottery-ticket projects.





