Brief: Trump the Babyface, Trump the Heel (w/Abraham Josie Reisman)
Jan 4, 2025
auto_awesome
Journalist Abraham Josephine Reisman, known for her insights on pro wrestling and politics, discusses how Donald Trump's wrestling fandom shapes his political persona. She introduces the concept of 'neokayfabe,' where reality and fiction intertwine, making the public complicit in a spectacle of cruelty. Reisman explores Trump's theatricality and its implications for truth in politics, drawing parallels between wrestling archetypes and political dynamics. The conversation reveals how charisma in leadership echoes the performative nature of wrestling, complicating public perception.
Josie Reisman argues that Trump's political style, influenced by wrestling, blends fact and fiction, manipulating narratives for emotional engagement.
The podcast explores how Trump's duality of 'babyface' and 'heel' allows him to captivate audiences through performative politics rather than moral clarity.
Deep dives
The Intersection of Wrestling and Politics
The podcast discusses the parallels between Donald Trump's political strategies and the world of professional wrestling, specifically referencing Vince McMahon's influence on Trump. Both engage in a form of storytelling that blurs the lines between reality and performance, requiring audiences to navigate a complex landscape of fact and fiction. This confusion enables leaders like Trump to manipulate narratives and maintain control over their supporters, as they create spectacles that elicit emotional reactions rather than rational discourse. The concept of 'neo-Kayfabe' is introduced, where the audience is fully aware of the fiction yet still engages in it, allowing political figures to act without accountability.
Character Dynamics: Babyfaces and Heels
The podcast delves into the archetypes of 'babyfaces' and 'heels' in wrestling, explaining how these roles correspond to good and bad characters in politics. Trump often embodies both roles strategically, appealing to his base by simultaneously portraying himself as a victim and aggressor, thus captivating a diverse audience. This duality creates a dynamic where contradictions are not seen as hypocrisy but rather performance art, where the expectations of loyalty and entertainment overshadow moral clarity. Understanding these roles helps unpack how audiences can rally behind leaders who frequently flip their stances and manipulate public sentiment.
The Role of Spectacle in Governance
The discussion emphasizes how the spectacle in wrestling parallels the chaotic nature of Trump's administration, where the performance often overshadows actual governance. The confusion and sensationalism serve as a distraction from critical issues, allowing leaders to pursue questionable agendas without scrutiny. This mirrors how wrestling uses 'worked shoots'—blending scripted events with real emotions—illustrating the vulnerability of the audience caught between belief and disbelief. Such an environment is detrimental, as it prevents a clear understanding of reality, pushing society into deeper division and skepticism.
Cultural Reflections and Consequences
The podcast highlights the cultural implications of the interaction between neo-Kayfabe and contemporary politics, where traditional values are manipulated for entertainment purposes. This has created a political landscape where emotional truths resonate more profoundly than factual realities, leading to widespread misinformation and division. It reflects a society where the absurd becomes accepted, and the audience is drawn into a cycle of validating destructive narratives simply for entertainment. The conversation underlines the need for awareness and critical thinking among citizens to navigate a reality increasingly dominated by performance over substance.
Journalist and author Josie Reisman says we can’t understand the Trump era without understanding his life-long pro-wrestling fandom, and his bonds with one of his closest friends, WWE tycoon Vince McMahon.
Reisman argues that McMahon’s invention of “neokayfabe,” in which storylines and real life are purposefully and artfully confused, blurs the distinction between fact and fiction. It makes consumers, followers, and voters complicit in creating a spectacle of cruelty.
It’s the kind of argument that once seen, can’t be unseen. It helps explain the contradictory and performative politics of Trump—and how, under his leadership, the administrative state may not be destroyed by fascism directly, but by a theatre of cynicism and catharsis that will allow the latent fascism of the American Empire to explode.