Hub Dialogues: Margaret MacMillan on why Canadians should stop condemning their history

Feb 4, 2025

Margaret MacMillan, a distinguished Canadian historian and emeritus professor, dives into the complexities of Canada's historical narrative and identity. She addresses the rise of populism and the impact of Prime Minister Trudeau on national historical perspectives. MacMillan critiques the trend of 'anti-history' historians and emphasizes the necessity of a nuanced view of historical figures like Sir John A. Macdonald. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding Indigenous perspectives and the role of trained historians in combating misinformation.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Age of Confusion

The current era is an "age of confusion" or "polycrisis" due to overlapping global events.
The past 30 years of relative stability may have been an exception to historical trends.

ANECDOTE

Parallels to the 1930s

MacMillan recalls the 1930s and Hitler's rise, noting how easily power can shift.
She expresses concern about the current loss of faith in institutions, mirroring Weimar Germany.

INSIGHT

Trudeau's Impact on Canadian History

MacMillan believes Trudeau's focus on historical wrongs has fostered resentment among Canadians.
Many feel they are being unfairly judged for past actions, despite Canada's positive global image.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

War

Bob Woodward

In this book, Bob Woodward provides an intimate and sweeping account of one of the most tumultuous periods in presidential politics and American history. The narrative centers on President Joe Biden’s approach to managing the war in Ukraine and the Middle East conflict between Israel and Hamas, as well as Donald Trump’s efforts to regain political power. Woodward reveals the complexity and consequences of wartime back-channel diplomacy and decision-making, highlighting efforts to deter the use of nuclear weapons and prevent a rapid slide into World War III.

Nineteen Eighty-Four

George Orwell

Published in 1949, 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' is a cautionary tale set in a future where the world is divided into three totalitarian super-states: Oceania, Eurasia, and Eastasia. The novel follows Winston Smith, a minor functionary in the Ministry of Truth in Oceania, who begins to question the all-pervasive authority of the Party and its leader, Big Brother. Winston's rebellion, fueled by his forbidden love affair with Julia and his interest in the mysterious Brotherhood, ultimately leads to his capture and brutal reeducation by the Thought Police. The novel explores themes of mass surveillance, censorship, and the manipulation of truth, serving as a powerful warning about the dangers of unaccountable governments and the erosion of individual freedom and dignity.

Paris 1919: Six Months That Changed the World

Margaret MacMillan

This book provides an in-depth look at the Paris Peace Conference, where men and women from around the world gathered to shape the peace after 'the war to end all wars'. The conference, dominated by figures like Woodrow Wilson, David Lloyd George, and Georges Clemenceau, saw the redrawing of maps, the creation of new countries, and the establishment of the League of Nations. MacMillan brings to life the personalities, ideals, and prejudices of the leaders involved, detailing their struggles with issues such as the future of Russia, China, the Arabs, and the Jews. The book argues that the peacemakers, though often criticized, were not solely responsible for the subsequent global conflicts, and it refutes common notions about the path to World War II.