Rebecca McLaughlin, an insightful author on sexuality and Christianity, joins biblical scholars Christopher and Richard Hays. They delve into evolving perspectives on sexuality within Scripture, discussing their new book, The Widening of God's Mercy. The conversation challenges the traditional views of God's unchanging nature, introduces the idea of divine changeability, and critiques modern interpretations of biblical sexuality. They emphasize the need for compassion while remaining rooted in scriptural truths, all while exploring the complexities of faith and relationships.
The discussion highlights the importance of recognizing individual agency in managing same-sex attractions, emphasizing that people can choose not to act on them.
The podcast critiques the notion of God changing His moral directives, arguing this conflicts with classical Christian theology about God's unchangeable nature.
It underscores the biblical definition of marriage as a union between one man and one woman, stressing the need for scriptural adherence in discussions of sexual ethics.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Same-Sex Attraction
The discussion emphasizes the dehumanizing notion that individuals with long-term same-sex attractions have no agency over their desires. It argues against the belief that such individuals cannot say no to their romantic or sexual feelings, highlighting that many people experience same-sex attraction without acting on it. The conversation positions scriptural interpretation as a means to uplift individuals struggling with these feelings rather than dismiss them outright. This perspective encourages a nuanced understanding of sexuality within the Christian faith, calling for both compassion and adherence to biblical teachings.
Critique of Changing God’s Mind
The critique focuses on the idea presented in the discussed book that God changes his mind regarding moral directives, particularly concerning sexual ethics. This concept is deemed problematic, as it conflicts with classical Christian beliefs about God’s unchangeable nature. The authors stress the pastoral implications of suggesting that God may alter his character or commandments based on contemporary cultural pressures. By using biblical narratives such as Jonah's experience, the argument posits that instances of divine 'relenting' should not be misconstrued as God reconsidering his moral imperatives.
Understanding the Biblical View of Marriage
The conversation addresses the fundamental nature of marriage as defined in the Bible, asserting that it is an exclusive union between one man and one woman. It highlights the lack of discussion in the book regarding the foundational scriptural passages that establish this definition, such as Genesis 2 and Jesus's teachings in Matthew 19. Furthermore, it critiques the omission of essential New Testament teachings that emphasize this model as a portrayal of Christ's relationship with the Church. This absence of any thorough exploration of biblical marriage principles in the book raises significant concerns about its conclusions on sexual ethics.
The Risk of Expanding Definitions of Love
The potential implications of broadening the definitions of love and relationships, particularly regarding polyamory, are examined. The argument can extend from the book's suggestions, making it difficult to draw clear moral lines when defining acceptable relationships. The discussion emphasizes that love should include the deep connections found in non-romantic friendships, advocating for a sense of community and brotherhood. Ultimately, this underscores the necessity of adhering to scriptural teachings while fostering genuine love and support within the Church.
The Nature of True Compassion
The importance of compassion is reaffirmed, elaborating that true love involves guiding individuals toward repentance and understanding of Christ’s teachings. The conversation highlights that while welcoming all sinners, the Church should also maintain clear standards based on biblical teachings. The discussion calls for the Church to become a community where believers support one another in overcoming sin rather than simply affirming it. This holistic love points towards the ultimate fulfillment found in Christ, reaffirming that his sacrificial love is what truly offers hope and reconciliation to all.
Gavin Ortlund and Rebecca McLaughlin discuss a new book on sexuality in the Bible by Christopher and Richard Hays, entitled The Widening of God’s Mercy: Sexuality Within the Biblical Story.
Rebecca's review:
https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/reviews/widening-gods-mercy/
Rebecca's book, Does the Bible Affirm Same-Sex Relationships:
https://www.amazon.com/Relationships-Examining-Scripture-Sexuality-homosexuality/dp/1784989711
Rebecca's book, Confronting Christianity:
https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Christianity-Questions-Largest-Religion/dp/1433564238
Gavin's video on slavery in the Bible:
https://youtu.be/ZImmDmr8pxk?si=pgareHjgt20j-OMk
Truth Unites exists to promote gospel assurance through
theological depth.
Gavin Ortlund (PhD, Fuller Theological Seminary) is
President of Truth Unites and Theologian-in-Residence at Immanuel Nashville.