Why Credit Unions Could Lose Big in Washington’s Regulatory Reset with John McKechnie

www.marktreichel.com

https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-treichel/

Episode Title: "Credit Unions at a Crossroads: Regulator Consolidation and the Tax Threat"

With Flying Colors Podcast | Episode [Number] | Released February [XX], 2025

Host: Mark Treichel
Guest: John McKechnie, John Ney LLC, Credit Union Policy Expert  

Overview:
In this timely episode, recorded just ahead of the 2025 Governmental Affairs Conference (GAC), Mark Treichel sits down with John McKechnie, a seasoned credit union advocate and former NCUA insider, to unpack the seismic shifts brewing in Washington, D.C. With the Trump administration signaling a potential overhaul of financial regulators and whispers of taxing credit unions, the stakes couldn’t be higher. Will NCUA get swept into a bank-dominated regulatory merger? Could the credit union tax exemption be on the chopping block? John and Mark dive into the uncertainty, the risks, and what it all means for the credit union movement.

Key Discussion Points:  

• Regulatory Consolidation Buzz: The Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg report on merging FDIC and OCC into Treasury—what does this mean for NCUA and credit unions? John shares insights from Capitol Hill, including a revealing chat with Senator Tim Scott’s staff.  
• The Share Insurance Fund Risk: How a consolidated regulator could swallow the credit union-backed fund into a bank-centric FDIC system.  
• Taxation Tensions: Banks push to tax “mega” credit unions—are we facing a divide-and-conquer strategy? John breaks down the political and economic arguments credit unions must wield.  
• Exam Burden Reality: NCUA’s lighter touch vs. bank regulators—could credit unions face 35% more scrutiny under a merged system?  
• GAC Game Plan: Why this year’s hill visits might be the most critical yet, and how credit union advocates can make their voices heard.  
• CFPB’s Future: A leaner, less aggressive CFPB under Trump—good news or a distraction from bigger threats?

Notable Quotes:  

• “The deck is being reshuffled right now, and I think credit unions should be concerned.” – John McKechnie  
• “If you eliminate the credit union tax exemption, you’re raising taxes on 220,000 of your constituents.” – John McKechnie  
• “This GAC could be as important as any visit to D.C. the movement has ever had.” – Mark Treichel

Why Listen?
With uncertainty as the word of the day, this episode is your insider’s guide to the regulatory and legislative battles that could redefine credit unions. Whether you’re flying into GAC or tracking policy from afar, Mark and John deliver the wisdom you need to understand the stakes—and what’s next.