All Songs Considered Listener Poll: Your Favorite Albums of 2025
25 snips
Dec 19, 2025 Music critic Sheldon Pearce joins to delve into the results of a listener poll on the top albums of 2025. They analyze fan reactions to Taylor Swift's surprising rankings and explore Hayley Williams' emotionally resonant work. The duo highlights the return of Clipping and the unique energy of Wet Leg's tracks. They discuss how Bad Bunny's genre-blending album appeals broadly, as well as Rosalía's theatrical pop masterpiece that topped the list. Tune in for insights on this year's music highlights and year-end reflections.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Listeners Wanted Emotional Escape
- Listener polls revealed surprising diversity: legacy stars, breakthrough bands, and genre crossovers filled the top 10.
- The results show listeners sought music that offered hope, escape, and emotional connection in 2025.
Bon Iver's Dual-Audience Appeal
- Bon Iver's Sable Fable bridged his folk past and newer pop/R&B leanings, drawing continued listener interest.
- Sheldon Pearce noted the record occupies both classic Bon Iver and a pop-soul pivot that attracts fans.
Fanbase Size Beats Mixed Reviews
- Taylor Swift's The Life of a Showgirl landed high despite mixed reviews because of her massive, dedicated fanbase.
- Robin Hilton and Sheldon Pearce suggest fandom scale can outweigh critical reception.