Explore the power of rumors in shaping our world, from the execution of enslaved men accused of witchcraft in Illinois to the legends of powerful witches like Eva Locker and Black Annie. Discover the impact of rumors throughout history, including murder accusations and mysterious behavior in witch trials.
Rumors have the power to shape historical events, like the rumor of King Louis XV being a leper and bathing in the blood of children leading to protests and threats against the king, planting seeds of the coming revolution.
Rumors can endure over time, as seen in the tales of Black Annie and Eva Locker, mythical figures fueled by superstitious rumors, highlighting the power of rumors to create enduring legends.
Deep dives
The Power of Rumor: From Paris to the American Midwest
In this podcast episode, the speaker discusses the power of rumors and how they can shape historical events. The episode begins by exploring a rumor in Paris during King Louis XV's reign, where it was believed that the king had become a leper and was bathing in the blood of children. This rumor led to protests and threats against the king, planting the seeds of the coming revolution. The episode then shifts to the American Midwest in 1779, where two men were executed for witchcraft by poisoning people. However, their executions were later sensationalized, and the rumors lingered, turning them into mythical figures. The speaker highlights the danger of rumor and emphasizes the importance of separating fact from fiction.
Rumor and Superstition: Black Annie and Eva Locker
This section of the podcast explores two tales of mythical figures fueled by rumors and superstition. The first tale revolves around Black Annie, a mysterious woman in black who was believed to haunt dairy farms in southern Illinois. The locals attributed her with magical powers, such as milking neighboring farms through a towel and killing cattle with hairballs. The second tale is about Eva Locker, a supposed witch who lived in Davis Prairie or David Prairie. She was reputed to have the ability to cast spells and cause misfortune to others. The speaker highlights the similar legends in British folklore and the power of rumors to endure over time.
Rumors and Witchcraft: The Troubled Case of James Sbiva
The podcast delves into an account of witchcraft accusations and rumors in Illinois involving James Sbiva and his encounters with alleged witches. The story begins with James falling ill, experiencing misfortunes, and attributing them to being bewitched. He seeks help from his brother, a self-proclaimed witch doctor, who advises James to harm the suspected witches. Eventually, James confesses to murdering one of the witches and faces trial. Despite inconsistencies, rumors persisted, leading to his arrest again in connection with witchcraft accusations against his wife. The trial ends with James being found not guilty, but the stigma remains. The episode underscores the dangers of rumors and their potential consequences.
Rumors might not always represent the truth, but that doesn’t mean they don’t have the power to change the world around us. Or—in some cases—give birth to frightening stories.
Written and produced by Aaron Mahnke, with research by Cassandra de Alba and Taylor Hagerdorn, and music by Chad Lawson.